2 ms·
> how many percent Americans would have voted yes to something like this if they had been asked directly? That seems an unfair burden. Many laws cover complex
by HWR_14 5y ago
> how many percent Americans would have voted yes to something like this if they had been asked directly?
That seems an unfair burden. Many laws cover complex matters and the average American cannot be expected to know the pros and cons of every bill. I like clean water, for instance, but my opinion on what that means isn't well developed enough to vote on laws on exactly what should be permitted.
- twofornone 5y ago>Many laws cover complex matters and the average American cannot be expected to know the pros and cons of every bill Our lawmakers aren't exactly subject matter experts either. And their SMEs are probably often just lobbyists.
- HWR_14 5y agoThis is a fair complaint, and I would welcome a better way for the lawmakers to obtain SME input.
- andreasley 5y agoDescribing the right to influence legislation as a burden seems exceptionally strange to me. Maybe that's because I've always lived in a direct democracy where it's commonplace to propose or challenge new laws, and while engaging in that process does require a few hours every now and then, I've always felt that's more than worth it.
- HWR_14 5y agoI'm not saying that the right to influence legislation is a burden. I'm saying, asking, poll-style, how many Americans would vote for X without any education or informed debate is a bad argument. By all means, I very much support citizen led initiatives (and there have been some excellent ones), but not out of the blue as an after the fact evaluation of a law.