5 ms·
I don't buy the early part. 3 years into the internet we already had emails and tcp. 13 years into blockchains we have nothing.
by epolanski 5y ago
I don't buy the early part. 3 years into the internet we already had emails and tcp. 13 years into blockchains we have nothing.
- oblio 5y agoWe have something! We have a ton of money in unregulated markets sloshing around reinventing every financial scam known to man. That's got to be something!
- cblconfederate 5y agoThis but unironically. Let's put that money to use to build good things, not more pyramids. All money was tainted at some point in the past. The modern world used to be very corrupt and violent - everywhere.
- RoboTeddy 5y agoWhen writing code for a blockchain today, even on an Ethereum L2, you're in a very resource-constrained environment where you end up using bitpacking tricks and the like. That's how it was for early computers, too, of course — they may serve as a better analogy. Programmable computers have taken decades to develop, beginning in ~1950, and I expect that decentralized computation will follow a similar path. There simply are numerous hard problems to solve to make this all work at greater scale. In a healthy ecosystem like Ethereum's, there are frequent research discoveries (discovery of the concept of data availability, the application of BLS signature aggregation, proposer-builder separation, zkevm, data availability sampling, ...). The software engineering effort required to implement such research is colossal as well. Eventually we'll even see e.g. specialized hardware for efficiently producing or verifying zero-knowledge proofs. It would be easy to look at the very early computers, which were perhaps not all that useful, and shrug — but that take wouldn't have extended well into the future as the technology scaled.
- giantrobot 5y ago> It would be easy to look at the very early computers, which were perhaps not all that useful, and shrug — but that take wouldn't have extended well into the future as the technology scaled. Early computers solved problems they were designed to solve. So they were plenty useful. Your statement is nonsensical.
- Liron 5y agoEarly computers augmented or replaced humans whose job title was “computer”
- RoboTeddy 5y agoEarly blockchains have also solved the problems they were designed to solve. For example: - Bitcoin offers a transferrable store of value which cannot be inflated by governments, - Stablecoins, thanks to being cross-border, are often used in e.g. Argentina where the local currency is unstable and it's not legal to buy dollars, - Proof of Humanity + universal basic income has provided extra income to Argentinian people (e.g. heard of someone who was able to purchase a ticket to visit their family for Christmas thanks to crypto UBI), - Crypto has been used to send remittances to economically unstable places (Lebanon, Turkey, Venezuela) - Gitcoin has provided public goods funding and advanced our conception of mechanism design, - Helium has created a new 5G network that people can actually roam onto, - NFTs have provided a new funding model for artists (who create public goods), - Zcash and Monero have allowed for fully private digital transfers, - Dark Forest (https://zkga.me/ https://zkga.me/) has been an amusing game, - Snapshot has helped create a delegative voting system that governs a $3B treasury, These might not be problems that you face or believe are important, but all these are examples of intended problems being solved. P.S. the tone of your comment made me a little sad :(
- astrange 5y ago> - Crypto has been used to send remittances to economically unstable places (Lebanon, Turkey, Venezuela) This would be cheaper if you didn't use the crypto part. The reason people use crypto is just that the governments have not yet noticed they're running an illegal money transmitter.
- canoebuilder 5y agoThere simply are numerous hard problems to solve to make this all work at greater scale. In a healthy ecosystem like Ethereum's, there are frequent research discoveries (discovery of the concept of data availability, the application of BLS signature aggregation, proposer-builder separation, zkevm, data availability sampling, ...). The software engineering effort required to implement such research is colossal as well. Ok, so there is a massive amount of effort to be put forth to get something out of this, and even then it is still kind of up in the air what that "something" actually is. Would it not be prudent to have at least some sort of roughly sketched map of what all this effort is supposed to bring about? other than Lambos... Or maybe ask if we would be better served if all that effort was put forth in some other direction? Man hours are not a limitless resource.
- RoboTeddy 5y ago> what all this effort is supposed to bring about In the limit, all this effort brings about an artifact that could be thought of as a "magic" computer where: - Everyone trusts that the computer operates to spec, - Anyone (or any user interface) can type whatever they want into the terminal and press "enter", - Anyone (or any other computer program) can read state out, - The computer has immense amounts of storage and compute, - Anyone who wants to change the computer's state in some way that cannot be achieved by using the terminal can freely make a copy of the computer with whatever changes they want, and encourage others to use their version instead. What, one might wonder, would the use be? There are many, many potential uses — it almost boggles the mind — it's kind of like trying to imagine the uses of the internet when it was first invented. To name one example: you could use this magic computer to operate a VR metaverse, instead of relying on a centralized Facebook one. Failing to do that would lock meaningful sections of our lives into a single vendor whose motivation is profit. Using the magic computer instead would mean that the metaverse would operate according to its predefined rules (which could leave plenty of space for human elections or other forms of collective decision-making), and that if things went awry anyone could try to set us back on track by making a modified copy of the machine and raising awareness about using it instead. Just like regular computers, this magic computer could also have plenty of negative consequences. It depends on how people opt to use it. I think we'll probably have more luck adopting technology and trying to drive it in the right direction, though — the alternative is widespread Luddism, which might actually be a good idea, but I don't see a realistic path to achieving it. A lot of folks who are very skeptical of web3 due to its dark sides are probably people who probably have great values and, if they adopted web3, could probably do a lot to improve its trajectory.
- beoberha 5y agoIt’s extremely disingenuous to say we have “nothing”. The EVM and smart contracts really are amazing technology that I hope any technical person could appreciate, even if they don’t see a practical application.
- adam_arthur 5y agoI think OP was implying something of real world value. I can see the hypothetical value in decentralized computing/public database. Certain types of data could in theory be stored publicly, and anybody could build APIs around them. In particular, it would be cool if there was some common protocol and storage format for something like tweets, such that anybody could build Twitter client. Common protocol would especially benefit social media IMO. We've long collaborated on open source code, but this would be more akin to open source data. But all that being said, why has nothing real world value oriented materialized yet? The decentralized experience is worse, and there are privacy concerns around storing certain data publicly, I would guess. Can those problems be solved?
- atweiden 5y ago> But all that being said, why has nothing real world value oriented materialized yet? Because Ethereum was founded by early Bitcoiners to raise bitcoin for themselves, and the technology always came second to the pursuit of self-enrichment. Software projects can never lose their soul. If the soul was rotten from the very beginning, as the saying goes: “garbage in, garbage out”. I sincerely doubt if any of the inventors of the marketing phrase “web 3” ever thought it would come to this: where their investors are so desperate for yield that they begin taking the term seriously. Not that it matters to the founders of Ethereum, many of whom have long since become secretive Bitcoin billionaires. The Ethereum project is best described as a series of cynical courtship displays designed purely to bootstrap the “network effect” for their newly created confidence game called ETH, which in 2014 they sold to — to borrow their own legal terminology — “philanthropists” in exchange for “donations”. A process they swore up and down bore no similarity at all to a securities offering. People not privy to the way cryptocurrency works are shocked to find the various buzzwords hatched by the Ethereum people for their own self-enrichment in the described legacy era of ICOs turn out to be a whole lot of nothing. They shouldn’t be shocked, they should be embarassed for lowering themselves to investing in such a system, or angry if they did so in ignorance.
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoI don't buy the early part either, but "3 years into the internet we had emails and tcp" is the wrong way to critique it IMO. The "Internet" meaning IP was already the 3rd or 4th (or more) attempt at trying to create a computer networking standard. Predecessors to the internet include: ARPANET, Usenet, FidoNet, BBSes, and CYCLADES, if not more. By the way, Email existed on _all_ of these platforms before TCP or even IP. Usenet used UUCP to transfer Internet Messages (the format used by Email later on). FidoNet had EchoMail. BBSes had their own custom mail message like standards. The Internet also had a direct competitor in the form of France's MiniTel. In hindsight, it seems like "3 years into the internet we already had emails and TCP", but the seeds for these things had been in the works for a decade plus. It's a testament to the massive success of the internet that we _think_ in hindsight that "3 years into the internet we had emails and tcp".
- yawnxyz 5y ago3 years into the emails, we didn't have something as user-friendly as Hotmail or Gmail
- dopidopHN 5y agoI used Minitel 5 or 6 years before I ever connected to the internet. That stuff was clunky and frustrating.
- bambax 5y agoI used Minitel for many years. It worked well.
- p1esk 5y ago"3 years into the internet we already had emails and TCP", but the seeds for these things had been in the works for a decade plus I'm not sure what you mean. Nothing has been in the works for a decade plus in 1971 when the first email was sent - it just two years after the very first internet connection was made. In contrast, it's been 13 years since bitcoins appeared, and aside from a potentially easier way to pay for illegal goods, I don't see any useful applications of crypto technology.