3 ms·
It is very annoying in business. Arguing that two outcomes are equally likely when one has happened many more times than the other is an exercise in frustration
by roenxi 5y ago
It is very annoying in business. Arguing that two outcomes are equally likely when one has happened many more times than the other is an exercise in frustration. It takes a certain level of courage, charisma and stubbornness to argue that there is no evidence that 2nd best is just as good as best when there is a measurable difference between two options.
This is a big contributor to why markets perform so well in my humble opinion. People who see past the gambler's fallacy to the actual odds of things working get rewarded, and the people who assume the current leader must be doing something different and better than the competition get punished.
> When your variable disease is expressing its worst symptoms, you are likely to feel better in the future
This is the influence of time & the healing process, not a regression to the mean. Symptoms in a given sickness' progression aren't random variables in a practical sense. It goes no symptoms -> bad symptoms -> lingering symptoms -> better (or permanent symptoms, bad luck :[ ).
- jldugger 5y ago> Arguing that two outcomes are equally likely when one has happened many more times than the other is an exercise in frustration Are they actually equally likely though? Perhaps there comes a point where one must consider if observed outcomes match with assumed probabilities. Or are you just having arguments about whether the unfavored outcome is 'overdue.'
- roenxi 5y agoFunnily enough, I might have been thinking of the exact opposite of the Gambler's fallacy. My mistake, sorry. But it still seems related to me and I'll explain what I was thinking anyway: For reference: https://www.omnicalculator.com/statistics/coin-flip-probability https://www.omnicalculator.com/statistics/coin-flip-probabil... There is a 20% chance that in 7 coin flips there will be >5 heads. By symmetry, 40% chance that there are >=5 heads or >=5 tails. If you look at a series of events (say, annual results) and one has exceeded the other in 5/7 years, that doesn't tell us that one is consistently better than the other. But people aren't good at accepting that.
- jldugger 5y agowell, i'd frame that conversation in terms of confidence intervals. with only 7 trials you are not very confident a>b.
- HWR_14 5y agoI found you text very confusing, and then figured out your typo. > There is a 20% chance that in 7 coin flips there will be >5 heads. By symmetry, 40% chance that there are >=5 heads or >=5 tails. Your first example should say >=5 heads. (Also, your site says almost 23%, making it just over 45% for either via symmetry)
- contravariant 5y ago> This is a big contributor to why markets perform so well in my humble opinion. People who see past the gambler's fallacy to the actual odds of things working get rewarded, and the people who assume the current leader must be doing something different and better than the competition get punished. The problem with markets is that rewarding the people who can predict the market correctly isn't a particularly useful end result. What you wanted to happen is for the people who are best able to predict the market to determine the 'fair' price, but that's usually only guaranteed as a steady state which fails as soon as a market is even remotely volatile.