3 ms·
> I'd be interested in hearing from those who consider this a surprising result. To me it seems entirely expected, but with online echo-chambers being what they
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> I'd be interested in hearing from those who consider this a surprising result. To me it seems entirely expected, but with online echo-chambers being what they are I have no doubt my lack of surprise could just mean I'm in an informational cul-de-sac.
What people think causes wealth inequality: Low tax rates on higher income people.
What actually causes wealth inequality: Corporate mergers, consolidation, lack of antitrust enforcement.
When does Zuckerberg have more wealth? When Facebook has a 900 billion dollar market cap and he pays a 70% tax rate, or when Facebook has a ten billion dollar market cap and he pays a 30% tax rate? (Hint: 30% of 900 billion is a lot more than 70% of ten billion. Also, he doesn't pay the tax until he sells anyway, which he doesn't.)
The problem with all of these studies is that people think the top tax rates were significantly reduced during Reagan, which is around the same time we stopped enforcing antitrust, so they see the effect of the latter and ascribe it to the former.
But we can distinguish them because the first one never actually happened. The nominal tax rates decreased a lot during Reagan, but that's because it coincided with the closure of a ton of tax loopholes that meant that high income people never actually paid those rates. Government revenues as a percent of GDP have basically been flat since the end of WWII and are about the same now as they were under Kennedy and LBJ:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S
So any study that purports to use this to show what happens when you "lower taxes" faces the trouble that the tax lowering never really happened in practice.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoThat's very interesting. We just hear 'tax cuts for the rich' and just get angry about the privileged not paying their fair share. 'Tax cuts for the Rich' has become kind of a buzzword phrase, like defund the police or climate change. it sounds totally obvious on an emotional level but the devil is in the details.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIt's actually worse than that because we have a tax code that actively promotes corporate expansion. If you're Walmart and you're making money and you've got a billion dollars in after-tax profit, what do you do with it? You could reinvest the money in the company. Open more Walmarts. Then you have a billion dollars to invest. You could pay it out as dividends to the shareholders. Then the shareholders, they're investors, they go invest in something else. Somebody goes out and builds more Walmart competitors. But dividends are income, even if you reinvest them. So if Walmart keeps the money and uses it to build more Walmarts, they get a billion dollars. If they pay the money out to the investors to invest in something else, and there is a 15% tax rate on dividends, there is only $850M to invest in the competitors. That's a huge disadvantage for the competitors, which induces the shareholders to prefer to invest in building more Walmarts. Now guess what happens to that incentive if you raise the tax rate on dividends to 25%. We could fix this by making dividends a tax deduction to the corporation. Right now Walmart makes a dollar, they pay corporate tax on it, then if they reinvest it themselves, no more tax. If they pay it as a dividend, it's taxed again before it can be reinvested in anything else. If the dividend was a deduction to the corporation, it would be taxed either to the corporation or to the shareholder, but not both as it is now -- and so there would be no preference for keeping the money inside the corporation and increasing its size. This sounds like "tax cut for corporations / rich people" but it's really just doing away with the tax penalty for removing money from a corporation to invest it in a different one. Which is the thing that reduces wealth inequality.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoInteresting. >taxing dividends But even if the corporation reinvests that money back into the corporation instead of distributing dividends, wont shareholders have capital gains tax if they try to sell the stock after it increases in value from the reinvestment?
- jevoten 5y ago> When does Zuckerberg have more wealth? When Facebook has a 900 billion dollar market cap and he pays a 70% tax rate, or when Facebook has a ten billion dollar market cap and he pays a 30% tax rate? This is a bad example. All else being equal, society doesn't care if there's one 100-billionare, or 100 1-billionares, if the rest of the income- and wealth- distributions remain the same. What really drives the inequality is, as you noted, consolidation, lack of antitrust enforcement. When a market is reduced to a handful of companies, that don't compete, but collude. And lack of labor organization to serve as a counterweight. (This is meaningful because, if you split ownership of a company among more people, their personal wealth may be lower, but the company still acts as a unit on the market.)
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> (This is meaningful because, if you split ownership of a company among more people, their personal wealth may be lower, but the company still acts as a unit on the market.) That's the point of the example. Zuckerberg owns a given percentage of Facebook. That isn't what increases over time. If he ever wants to spend any of the money, that only ever goes down. The reason he's a multi-billionaire is that a given percentage of Facebook causes him to be when Facebook is a single 900 billion dollar company when it wouldn't if there were a hundred Facebooks each of 1% the size and he only owned the original percentage of one of them. > And lack of labor organization to serve as a counterweight. Labor organization is just a different kind of consolidation. It's only useful against a monopoly -- otherwise the business has thin margins and there is nothing for a labor monopoly to extract -- but the correct response to a business monopoly is to smash it to pieces.
- DarylZero 5y agoThey're all monopolies. Business competition itself is over control of monopolies.
- jayski 5y agoVery interesting comment. Im not arguing for or against antitrust laws, just adding to the conversation. If we had more companies competing in the same areas (5 equally sized search engines instead of google, 5 online shopping sites instead of Amazon, etc) - theres a strong possibility those 5 wouldnt be able to compete with giant international companies that arent subject to the same antitrust laws. (baidu, alibaba, etc) So I wonder if America is better off owning these tech giants with all the harm they cause, or not having them at all.