4 ms·
I totally agree with your premise. I used to work at google, and every time I go back there / talk to my old friends it breaks my heart a little. That said, yo
by josephg 15y ago
I totally agree with your premise. I used to work at google, and every time I go back there / talk to my old friends it breaks my heart a little.
That said, you've made two claims in your post:
1. All groups will get worse over time
2. Therefore, we should keep government as small as possible
The refutation to the argument is that many other modern democracies have (proportionally) bigger governments than the US. These countries certainly get advantages from big governments (like social welfare, decent education systems, state sponsored medical attention, etc) but don't seem to pay much of a cost for it.
As an Australian citizen, I will get paid a dole if I can't find work, all my important medical expenses are covered or heavily subsidised, our schools are decent everywhere, and so on. My taxes are a bit higher than yours, but not unreasonably so.
I suspect the important difference might just be scale - Australia has just 20M people. Most European countries have similar sizes. Maybe if the US were lots of small countries instead it would work better? Its hard to tell...
- lukeschlather 15y ago>Maybe if the US were lots of small countries instead it would work better? Its hard to tell... I'd just like to point out that we don't have a proper social welfare system here in the US, so it doesn't make sense to say that it might work better if we were a smaller country. The US has to actually enact a European-style social welfare system before anyone can empirically claim that social welfare doesn't work in the US.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoIt's funny. I almost mentioned Google -- both as a good example and a bad one. Just compare and contrast the organization over time. From the systems standpoint, Google is great. People continue to think that if we just got the right people -- smart, college-educated, libertarians, whatever -- that systems wouldn't ossify. But until you've seen a group of brilliant people self-create themselves a living hell, and realize that each person was acting in a reasonable, intelligent fashion, it's tough to really grok that. We naturally want to assign blame. It prevents us from doing the meta thinking necessary. One of the reasons democracies work so well is that we can easily assign personal blame to a politician, then peacefully get rid of him and bring somebody else in. There's a tremendously useful social mechanism at work. I think there's a separate discussion about what you want government to do for you. I've gotten to the point where after listening to so many idealists on both the left and right I just gave up: whatever your social goals, that's fine. I just want an acknowledgement that you are aware of he trade-offs you are creating. I prefer lots of little, agile, self-optimizing systems. I think over time people could probably reach many of the social goals they have. But to do so you need to have the right tools. You'll never get from point A to point B trying to use a screwdriver as a hammer. As an example a lot of us can relate to, there are a lot of technology teams with a huge amount of personal freedom that have all sorts of benefits and create vast amounts of value. We got that way by millions of little failures from which we harvest some generic best practices that then we pick up, try, and adapt one bit at a time for that particular situation. But there are even more folks, hundreds of thousands of people, living a death march because they tried to create huge systems with lots of little rules and processes. These huge systems never spring forth fully-formed from the head of Zeus. When you really start looking at them, it's a story of incrementalism and tough trade-offs. Everybody has a little architecture astronaut inside of them. Maybe not a lot, but enough to cumulatively screw things up given enough scale and time. If anything, smart people are the worst at this. They can even understand my points and try as hard as they can not to do it -- and still do it. Hominids are funny creatures.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThese countries certainly get advantages from big governments (like social welfare, decent education systems, state sponsored medical attention, etc) but don't seem to pay much of a cost for it. Most countries with systems more extensive than those of the US tend to be poorer than the US. http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-one-picture.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/super-economy-in-o... http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/income-distribution-in-us-and-sweden.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/03/income-distributio... http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/01/dynamic-america-poor-europe.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/01/dynamic-america-po... Also, we have social welfare, stated sponsored medical attention, and decent education systems in the US. Where did you get the idea we lack these things?
- jacques_chester 15y ago> Where did you get the idea we lack these things? The USA is used as a strawman in Australian politics. "We don't want to go down the American path" is an actual phrase in wide circulation.
- tmeasday 15y ago> Also, we have social welfare, stated sponsored medical attention, and decent education systems in the US. Where did you get the idea we lack these things? As an Australian who has spent a fair amount of time in the states I would argue with those points. Sure, you have those things, (not sure about 'decent' education system) but they certainly don't function as efficiently as ours do, as far as I can tell..
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIf the USA doesn't have a decent education system, then neither does Australia. At least according to demographically adjusted PISA scores. http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/12/amazing-truth-about-pisa-scores-usa.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2010/12/amazing-truth-abou...
- cabalamat 15y ago> As an Australian citizen, I will get paid a dole if I can't find work And if you can only find minimum wage work, you'll still be better off than most Americans or Britons.