3 ms·
I mostly agree, though I don't have a strong position on the correct answer. But as someone who does study complex systems sometimes in my day job, I find that
by _delirium 15y ago
I mostly agree, though I don't have a strong position on the correct answer. But as someone who does study complex systems sometimes in my day job, I find that argument for libertarianism extremely unconvincing. Most complex systems you find do not, left alone, function in any sort of reasonable way. They are full of crazy oscillating attractors, pathological feedback loops, more-stable and less-stable states that you (or an actor in the system) can deliberately manipulate it into, etc., etc. "Well-behaved" dynamical systems are comparatively hard to design even when you're deliberately designing, and ones you just find somewhere are usually not well behaved.
Which makes me particularly skeptical of "the market just works" type analysis, which claims that this particular complex dynamical system does not have all those pathologies, and in fact can be analyzed with fairly high-level, aggregate laws like the classical economics analysis of supply/demand adjustment. Heck, even fluid dynamics (another complex system) doesn't work that way--- all our general laws about how pressure/flow/velocity/etc. relate only apply to specific flow regimes, and can have different or even opposite-of-normal relationships in different flow regimes (especially anything turbulent).
One argument for why there should be some intervention would be: the classical-economics analysis of how economies should work is an appealing one, but is not in fact how they always work, so the government's job should be to dampen out the pathologies and turbulence that would take us out of the "normal" regime where the classical laws do apply. That's sort of the line taken by ordoliberalism. The question would be whether it can, on the whole, do more good than harm. But I wouldn't start from the assumption that what you get without government intervention operates "well" or "ideally".
- bermanoid 15y agoI think your concerns are absolutely spot on, and they match mine almost exactly - I've spent practically my whole working life modeling complex systems, and pathologies are the rule, not the exception, so it strikes me as unbelievably naive to just assume that there's something magical about free markets when in reality they are made up of millions of different entities with different objectives, costs, and constraints. Even when you're simulating a system that's provably stable, when simulation errors and noise creep in, you're batting about 50/50 as to whether your particular simulation method will go off the rails or not (as anyone that's ever tried to simulate a damped harmonic oscillator starting from Newton's laws and the obvious method of approximating a derivative knows quite well). In simulation we take stability arguments and proofs very seriously, the presumption being that if you can't prove that a system is stable, you can't assume anything about it (the exception being physical processes, where stability of the underlying can usually be taken as a given because of anthropic principal arguments and we're merely tasked with finding the proof, as well as a simulation scheme that doesn't screw up - that's a lot more difficult than it sounds, especially for complex systems like fully relativistic gravity). These concerns are of the utmost priority in most fields that involve complex systems, especially processes that we have a hand in influencing, except for economics and politics, where everyone's pet arguments are balls to the wall, and tend to either imply that we should be living with full blown communism or complete unregulated anarchy (okay, I suppose contract law and the military are typically carved out as the exceptions). It's one of the few areas I've ever seen where none of the popular arguments seem to have any sort of balance - and I'm not talking "balance" as in fairness, I'm talking about "balance" as in trivial idea that if both extremes suck (which they usually do, whatever particular idea or disagreement you're arguing over), and something in between is better, then there exists some optimum between the extremes. Step one involves admitting that either extreme has a problem, but instead everyone seems to keep arguing that the whole problem is just that we're not actually at that extreme, 100%.
- wjy 15y agoThank you both _delirium and bermanoid. You have managed to express my sentiments exactly, but much more eloquently than I could have. I am always so frustrated by the notion of "the market is always right". As if a system with billions of complex actors could somehow be described like a first order linear system, that will always find a stable equilibrium.