3 ms·
I find it interesting that you use the recent home mortgage crisis as an example of market failure. Libertarians often use it as an example of governmental fail
by SwellJoe 15y ago
I find it interesting that you use the recent home mortgage crisis as an example of market failure. Libertarians often use it as an example of governmental failure. Markets and governments were involved in the creation and fallout of the crisis...and people on either side want to blame the other. It's actually pretty analogous to the problem Eliezer pointed out about the balance of heredity vs. environment.
While the mortgage crisis would not have happened without market forces (+ human greed) and government involvement. The question becomes which of those factors we can alter or remove to make such an occurrence impossible in the future, rather than which factor to blame. From a pragmatic perspective, since we can't remove human greed, the other option is to not implement government programs that make it easier for millions of people who can't afford a house to get a mortgage.
So, more government might have prevented the problem, perhaps in the form of education programs for home buyers who only qualified because of the government programs. But, less government could have prevented the problem, as well, since the vast majority of those loans would have never happened without government programs to encourage them.
My instincts tell me to go the less expensive route, and let the market decide who can afford a house or not. If a bank knows the government isn't going to bail them out (as would be the case if these loans weren't government-backed), they're going to be more careful about who gets those loans.
- yequalsx 15y agoI was only providing an example of how libertarian principles don't always scale. I said nothing about the housing market in the U.S. and I don't know why you bring up the U.S. housing market. From what I've read about libertarianism (the economic principles of libertarianism) it is highly impractical. It seem like a set of principles that work at the local level provided there is plenty of competition. Libertarian principles don't scale at a macro level. Especially in the presence of cartels or monopolies. Or in an environment when risk is being transferred to parties who don't understand the risk that is being transfered to them and when this risk transfer is being done on a truly massive scale.
- SwellJoe 15y ago"One person who buys a house they can't really afford is not a big deal. Let such a person make that bad decision if this is their inclination is a libertarian attitude. But millions of people make a similarly bad decision affects us all." I assumed you were describing a recent real-world scenario where exactly this occurred. What did you have in mind, if not the recent US mortgage crisis? It seems, to me, that real examples are more useful than imagined ones. If we are using imaginary problems, we can come up with all sorts of interesting solutions, but they don't necessarily carry over to real world problems. Thought experiments can be useful tools, but when the results conflict with reality, you have to be willing to adjust and accommodate new data. "Especially in the presence of cartels or monopolies." Which cartels and monopolies do you have in mind? The biggest monopolies and cartels I can think of in the US are those that have government support to protect their monopoly. Phone, cable, power, water, are the most firmly held monopolies (occasionally duopolies) in the US, for instance, and all are protected by government. Toll roads in the northeast are another good example of government-endorsed monopolies (I'm not saying the toll roads are necessarily a bad thing, just that they are solidly a monopoly; you can't really drive from NYC to anywhere without travelling on those toll roads, and they are, by far, the most expensive toll roads I've ever driven on, and I travel full-time in a motorhome, so I've seen a lot of toll roads). Microsoft was frequently called a monopoly for several years, but the market eventually removed those monopolistic powers. Anti-trust actions barely put a dent in their power, and targeted quite small, quite unimportant elements. The market is where the real change came from. Heck, many of the remaining strongholds for Microsoft are in governments, which are unable to move as fast as private organizations. And, a not insignificant amount of Microsoft's power came from having a stranglehold on government schools, offices, etc. I can't think of many other good monopoly examples that aren't government-backed, though I'm sure there are some examples. I'm willing to believe that anti-trust legislation has a place; but I'm also very suspicious of the argument that all government is good government because monopolies and cartels are dangerous, which seems to be the root of your bias against libertarianism or reduced government.
- nerfhammer 15y agoPerhaps the reason you have trouble thinking of monopolies that aren't government sanctioned is because anti-trust law already prohibits monopolies from forming unless government sanctioned. The exceptions that are sanctioned are examples in economic theory of "natural monopolies", typically utilities, where competition would be highly impractical. For example, it would be impractical to have many different competing networks of privately owned telephone poles, sewer lines, water lines, etc. serving the same municipality. So a natural monopoly is allowed to exist but is heavily regulated and may face price controls. see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly
- scott_s 15y agosince the vast majority of those loans would have never happened without government programs to encourage them. I'm going to copy-and-paste something I said before on this topic (which was actually a reply to jerf): I slogged through much of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Report (http://fcic.law.stanford.edu/ http://fcic.law.stanford.edu/). One of the conclusions was that while mandating loans didn't help, they weren't numerous enough to be a major cause. Because of the mortgage-backed securities industry, there was incentive for banks to make sub-prime loans and offload the loans (and the risk) elsewhere. Once the MBS engine got churning, there was an enormous demand for more loans to feed it. In other words, the government's requirements did not lead to the glut of sub-prime loans. Education for the home-buyers would probably not work. I can't remember which author it was who made this point, but on reading about the crisis, someone pointed out that people will take what you give them. That's not really fixable. The fixable problem was that banks were willing to make such loans. And they were willing to make such loans not because they knew the government would bail the loans out, but because the banks would not keep the loans. They'd turn around and sell the loans to investment banks that packaged the loans up into MBSs. The banks making the sub-prime loans weren't the same banks that were on-the-hook for them.
- inthewoods 15y agoActually the majority of the housing crisis would have been avoided had the government stepped in and simply required confirmation of income on mortgage applications. The lack of this simple and obvious requirement (which Obama put into place as soon as he came into office) allowed independent mortgage companies like Countrywide to put together ridiculous mortgages for people that could not afford it. Those same mortgage companies then sold the mortgages for packaging and had no risk. Thus, they were incentivized to get as many mortgages done as possible - regardless of the risk. From my point of view, this is a classic example of where government regulation not only makes sense, but keeps market participates from creating abnormal risk.