5 ms·
> That it is currently more economical to use fossil fuels is a separate issue. That's not a separate issue. That's the WHOLE issue. The first 2 words in the q
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> That it is currently more economical to use fossil fuels is a separate issue.
That's not a separate issue. That's the WHOLE issue. The first 2 words in the quote were "Modern agriculture". The point is not that there are many types of farming that can be done without using fossil fuels as an input, nor that in the future we couldn't transition away from fossil fuels for fertilizer. The point is that the output of modern agriculture would, at present, completely collapse if the energy input from fossil fuels wasn't available.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThat latter point is false, though except in a trivial sense. Hydrogen can be and is easily made with electricity. There is plenty of clean electricity available to do it. Also, 50% of the energy does not come from fixed nitrogen. Majority is from the Sun.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoThere currently aren’t enough green hydrogen > ammonia manufacturing plants on the planet to do this though. Building the necessary renewable energy and ammonia plants and infrastructure is technically trivial in that we needed approximately no innovation as the tech already exists. The scaled of the problem is immense.
- Robotbeat 5y agoIt’s not immense compared to almost anything else we’ve done (such as the transition to air conditioning… air conditioners consume about 6% of US electricity). To replace all US ammonia production would require less than 5% of US electricity (see my other post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29842105 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29842105). Heck, you can get about halfway there just on the nuclear power plants in the US that have been shut down in the last couple decades! (Works well with intermittent renewables, too, as hydrogen production can be throttled without much penalty.)
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoIn what way is building forty odd new nuclear reactors not an immense undertaking? Or the equivalent in new renewables, if that’s your preference.
- Robotbeat 5y agoAgain, we used to double grid capacity every decade or so. An extra 5 percent is nothing in comparison to what we did doubling electricity production each decade from roughly the 40s through the 70s. (And that’s about 10-20 new nuclear reactors, not 40. A fraction of our current nuclear fleet.)
- tuatoru 5y ago> That latter point is false, though except in a trivial sense. Hydrogen can be and is easily made with electricity. You mean, except in a $Trillion sense. One or two demonstrator plants don't prove anything, except that the advantages are underwhelming, if they exist at all. How do we globally get there from here? Who is made worse off? Who benefits? How long does it take? "Exercises for the student" are not always so simple.
- tough 5y agoI was watching fall of civilizations channel the other day on youtube, it was indeed eerie to see how most great civs depleted their soils and natural resources, and that with some drought times, put the civilization to its end. I just noticed, before these civs would be geographically separated and isolated, the demise of one, didn´t mean the demise of the other, and the people that had settled and survived, would become nomadic until settling again or something like that. What will happen when this global civ collapses? Where would the survivors be able to go to, to persist? Nowhere? Dark indeed
- duped 5y agoI think that hypothesis needs to be challenged or at least framed differently, since there aren't that many examples of civilizations that "reverted" to nomadism from an agrarian society (it would probably be more accurate that climate change/human activity dampened agricultural output enough that nomadic peoples became more prevalent as the population of agrarian peoples collapsed/migrated elsewhere), at least outside larger contexts like the Bronze Age Collapse where there was a centuries long period of population decline in a large geographic area. And in more recent centuries, "collapse" is almost always synonymous with political turmoil/change while the peoples remain in place. I think that's important too, because we're not seeing so much of a "collapse" of our global civilization, but migrations of peoples across it, and a rise in political turmoil as a second order effect.
- pstuart 5y ago> Where would the survivors be able to go to, to persist? Mars! /s, kinda We have the science and technology to address these issues, the thing that fucks us is our political/economic/religious structures. If we collectively agreed on solving these problems we could, but unity seems to be the scarcest resource of all.
- dane-pgp 5y agoGlobal society has slightly different dynamics, though, because of emergent properties of that scale. For example, countries or even some continents could suffer ecological collapse without global society necessarily being threatened. The other side of that coin, though, is that global society has introduced global risks, in terms of the amount of CO2 it is able to put into the atmosphere (which is a shared resource we all rely on), and the ability to create weapons or pathogens of global destruction due to technology.