7 ms·
There is a great quote I heard once that many people don't realize: "Modern agriculture is the conversion of the energy in fossil fuels to energy in food we can
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
There is a great quote I heard once that many people don't realize: "Modern agriculture is the conversion of the energy in fossil fuels to energy in food we can eat".
That is, the vast majority of nitrogen-fixation for fertilizers is done using natural gas or other petroleum product: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonia_production
- UncleOxidant 5y agoCouldn't we extract all the nitrogen we need from sewage?
- ivarv 5y agoI don't know if we could get all the required nitrogen to sustain our current agricultural methods, but there are definitely people working towards normalizing the capture and reuse of the nutrients in urine. Our current practice of polluting waterways with our urine is a travesty though, and it behooves us to process our 'waste' in a more regenerative way. See https://richearthinstitute.org https://richearthinstitute.org for more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- time_to_smile 5y agoI'm surprised by how little people understand the relationship between fossil fuels (not just energy) and global food production. The primary reason that Malthus was wrong in his predictions about population growth and food supply isn't because of "science" it's because of fossil fuels. This wouldn't be an issue if fossil fuels were unlimited in supply and didn't have very severe externalities in their unrestricted usage. People don't like to talk about what the food supply looks like under a zero emissions scenario with our current nitrogen productions methods. edit: This comment getting quickly downvoted is objective evidence for my argument that "People don't like to talk about..." There's nothing controversial in this comment. In a world without fossil fuels we very likely would have seen Malthus's predictions come to be, fossil fuels are obviously a limited resource and their usage has extreme externalities. I get that people are scared, but it's still sad to see a community of otherwise curious people start to break down when they see facts that make them uncomfortable.
- agumonkey 5y agoso malthus wasn't wrong, he was just early :)
- Enginerrrd 5y ago>People don't like to talk about what the food supply looks like under a zero emissions scenario with our current nitrogen productions methods. I'd have to run the numbers... but offhand I'd guess it just means nitrogen gets 2.5x more expensive. (Call it 2-10x if you want some padding) That doesn't even mean food gets 2.5x more expensive, only that the percentage of costs due to nitrogen go up that much. I think this is such a non-issue.
- elil17 5y agoAbsolutely true. Food inflation in the US is about the same as average inflation. We’re not paying more for food in comparison with other goods than we were a year ago.
- sremani 5y agoWe are evaluating the an upstream input cost and possible downstream effects. So, the consequences of high urea prices today will vividly show up sometime in the latter part of this year.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- elil17 5y agoIf that was true we would have seen a big spike in grain futures around September/October (when this data was published). Grain futures are up but the big spikes were in December, indicating that urea prices are not the cause. According to some articles I’ve read targeted towards farmers [1], they are able to compensate by using less fertilizer-dependent crops. So, we can expect small price hikes and major shifts towards using soybeans in place of corn where possible. [1] example: https://www.agriculture.com/markets/analysis/crops/fertilizer-dilemma-has-farmers-on-edge-analyst-says https://www.agriculture.com/markets/analysis/crops/fertilize...
- Enginerrrd 5y agoThis is so disingenuous. The total energy input from fossil fuels is several fold less than the energy output since most of it is derived from the sun. [1](See figure 3) Around 50% of the input is indeed from nitrogen, but it need not be derived from fossil fuels since you could source energy elsewhere and use water electrolysis derived hydrogen in the nitrogen production process. That it is currently more economical to use fossil fuels is a separate issue. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2935130/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2935130/
- time_to_smile 5y ago> more economical In the same way that bunker fuel powered ships are just "more economical" than transporting goods by sail powered ships. People throw this term around like making it "less economical" to produce food is some minor detail. Things being their current level of "economical" is what drives our global economy at the current scale it runs at. We could not have our current lifestyle using sail powered ships to transport goods from China any more than we could maintain anything like our current lifestyle if we had to produce all of our nitrogen fertilizer through electrolysis. Making food "less economical" means mass starvation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kragen 5y agoIt sounds like you disagree with the calculations Robotbeat presented in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29842105 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29842105, but it is unclear whether that is because you have done calculations of your own. Please elaborate. Robotbeat's calculations seem to show that producing all of the US's nitrogen fertilizer through electrolysis would use something like 5% of US electricity production, which would not be a major obstacle to "maintaining anything like our current lifestyle", and presumably the numbers in other countries are even better, except for the Netherlands.
- 5y ago
- redconfetti 5y agoFossil fuels were created from sunlight, so really it's all solar.
- Frost1x 5y agoAnd a whole lot of time, temperature, and pressure driven through geological processes. Energy from gravity and radiation are contributing factors to fossil fuel production, even if the hydrocarbons broken down for use are largely photosynthetic in nature/origin, they owe their energy density that makes them a viable fuel source to factors beyond solar. Breaking that down has side effects beyond pure photosynthetic processes.
- alexpotato 5y agoEssentially it's all "when did those solar photons hit the earth" time based arbitrage.
- surfpel 5y agoSunlight is from fusion, so really it’s all nuclear.
- jka 5y agoExtrapolating from your comment (neither disagreeing or agreeing, primarily trying to provide additional resources for people to learn about and to help explore the option space): The history of ammonia production has led to a fossil fuel dependency chain. This article at resilience.org seems to include some good history: https://www.resilience.org/stories/2006-06-11/implications-fossil-fuel-dependence-food-system/ https://www.resilience.org/stories/2006-06-11/implications-f... One of the primary processes involved in the creation of ammonia is the Haber-Bosch process, as outlined on Wikipedia here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haber_process The International Energy Agency provides a good summary of a technology roadmap for migration of ammonia production processes to lower-emission methods: https://www.iea.org/reports/ammonia-technology-roadmap/executive-summary https://www.iea.org/reports/ammonia-technology-roadmap/execu... And finally - I've no connection with the University of Michigan but I did find this recent article about a research grant for solar-powered, energy-decentralized fertilizer production; I'm not clear on the details of the research yet but it does again re-iterate the nature of the problem and illustrates that there is effort directed towards overcoming fossil fuel dependence in this area: https://news.umich.edu/2m-to-replace-fossil-fuels-with-solar-power-in-fertilizer-production/ https://news.umich.edu/2m-to-replace-fossil-fuels-with-solar...
- kragen 5y agoI used to believe this, but it is a lie wrapped around a small kernel of truth. It is true that "the vast majority of nitrogen-fixation for fertilizers is done using" fossil fuels (mostly natural gas, which is not a petroleum product), but plants do not get their energy from those fertilizers. Moreover, the total energy obtained from agriculture is about five times greater than the energy input used to make fertilizers, as shown in https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2935130/figure/RSTB20100172F3/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2935130/figure/... (thanks Enginerrd).
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI agree, but I think you and others are missing the primary point of the quote, or interpreting it too literally (which is fair, that is what the quote says after all). The primary point is that agriculture, as it is currently practiced on a large scale, is extremely dependent on non-renewable resources and the energy in those resources. It's not just natural gas used for nitrogen, it's also things like phosphate mining. Yes, the amount of calories in the final product largely comes from the sun, but it is the energy in those (currently) petroleum products that unlocks a plant's ability to photosynthesize in the first place.
- kragen 5y agoEach of these problems needs to be considered on its own merits, not lumped together in some sort of misleading generalization. I was worried about the phosphate thing for a while since, unlike resources like copper and rare earth metals, the used phosphate mostly ends up in the oceans, not conveniently concentrated in landfills. Getting it back out of the oceans is pretty difficult. But then I looked into it a few years back. It turns out that the absolute amount of phosphate in crustal phosphate rocks is staggeringly huge: about 0.1% of the crust is phosphorus, almost all as phosphate, conventionally measured as P₂O₅, which would thus be 142/62 of that, or about 0.2%. This works out to be on the order of 10¹⁹ kg of phosphate. World phosphate production is 53 million tonnes (https://www.fao.org/3/i6895e/i6895e.pdf https://www.fao.org/3/i6895e/i6895e.pdf), less than 10¹¹ kg, so at current consumption rates we will run out of phosphate in about 10 million years. Given this, you might wonder why "phosphate reserves" are stated as only a few tens of billions of tonnes! The answer is that currently most phosphate minerals are unprofitable to mine because they can't compete on price with the fairly pure concentrated apatite deposits in the US, Morocco, and China. When those deposits are exhausted (probably sometime in the next few centuries), the price of phosphate will rise, unless we're mining it from the Moon or the asteroids by then. That will make it profitable to extract phosphate from less concentrated resources. So, while it is technically true that phosphate rock is a "nonrenewable resource", the implication that we will run out before the Pyramids have crumbled into dust is not. The bigger problem with phosphate mining is phosphogypsum, not energy consumption or running out of phosphate minerals. Detoxifying phosphogypsum is not a difficult chemistry problem, but there is a lot of it and nobody is paying to detoxify it, so it sits in waste dumps. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw a red-mud-style industrial disaster or two with phosphogypsum in the next few decades.
- xyzzy21 5y agoYou can say the same thing about all economics after the 1600s - wood, coal, whale oil, petroleum. There is a direct causal relationship between energy consumption and economic growth. End the former and you end the latter. And you also kill off a ton of people because the system that enables their lives will falter and starve them to death.