6 ms·
I think you are putting words into his mouth with the "this is broken, throw it out". The reason why unconventional governance models are treated with general s
by jerf 15y ago
I think you are putting words into his mouth with the "this is broken, throw it out". The reason why unconventional governance models are treated with general skepticism is one of the major points of the essay, which is that if the unconventional governance models are being designed and implemented by the same crew of people with the same basic beliefs that are dominant today, there's no particular reason to believe the outcome is going to be any different in the end. "What makes me a libertarian is that the prospect of having that reconfiguration done by the same system that managed to ban marijuana while allowing tobacco, subsidize ethanol made from corn, and turn the patent system into a form of legalized bludgeoning, makes me want to run screaming into the night until I fall over from lack of oxygen."
Also, characterizing the libertarian answer as "shut it all down" is a strawman in its own right. I daresay one of the major ideas that prevents people from understanding libertarianism is understanding that "let the market deal with it" is not anything remotely resembling "shut it all down". The market provides very sharp constraints on what actions one may profitably take, and one of the advantages of the market system is that said constraints are much more closely connected with reality than any other commonly proposed system is. As an also-little-l libertarian I don't deny that some further regulation may be necessary, but defying the market is less like defying people and more like defying physics. You will pay the price. (In fact, we are, right now.) In particular I strongly believe in the need for regulations that ensures that the market stays free, so I'm very in favor of regulations to prevent monopolies from forming, and very hostile to government-granted market monopolies.
If you understand the market as "it's all, like, greed man, and greedy people abusing other greedy people, and, like, evil, man", you really ought to spend some time understanding the theory of the market as an actual existing entity, rather than a politically-oriented strawman designed cognitively innoculate you against ideas that may actually change your mind if you were to truly learn about them. Perhaps it won't change your mind, but I'll say that most people online's efforts to pry me away from my libertarianism fails on the grounds that almost nobody actually understands it in the first place, which puts them at a bit of a disadvantage.
(Remember, almost nobody is raised libertarian. Few libertarians hold their beliefs unexamined, the way that those who were simply raised liberal or conservative can, though of course not all do.)
- nknight 15y agoWell, first, if you want to complain that I or anyone else don't understand libertarianism, I think you should first have a long chat with how your fellow professed libertarians portray it. Amongst other things, you're one of only two or three of the dozens of purported libertarians I've encountered who claim to be in favor of any commercial regulation beyond fraud and contract enforcement issues. The near-universal stance has been that monopolies are a natural byproduct of the free market, and not a "problem". As for the rest... Well, I've never had a problem with the idea that a properly competitive market would be far superior to where we are now, but libertarianism, at least as portrayed by professed libertarians, doesn't restrict itself to that. It seeks to completely tear down social safety nets in favor of that market and ditch environmental and safety regulations. My own experiences and those of my family are all that is necessary to convince me of the disaster that would result by going that far. I'm the last person who's going to defend the ridiculous things cited (marijuana/tobacco, corn ethanol, patents) and many others, but if you're being intellectually honest, you also have to look at the bad things that have resulted from unbounded market forces (serious pollution/poisoning, worker deaths, building collapses, ...) until government stepped in and imposed regulations on the "free market". There are tradeoffs here. If you don't think these things are part of libertarianism, you need a new name for your beliefs, because the existing one is too corrupted by people who either don't actually share your beliefs, or don't understand that they've done a horribly negligent job of explaining them.
- Jach 15y agoNaming issues get overlooked too often, I think, and it just asks for "no true Scotsman"-style discussions. The confusion you're having seems to be thinking that "Objectivist-style Libertarians", with no compromises, and self-proclaimed "small-l libertarians", of the type jerf and Eliezer belong, are the same when they're in fact pretty different.
- randallsquared 15y agoThe near-universal stance has been that monopolies are a natural byproduct of the free market, and not a "problem". There's a large subset (possibly the majority?) of libertarians who expect that monopolies are a byproduct of state intervention, and not a natural product of the free market, which is precisely why one shouldn't interfere in ways that lead to monopolies (among other ways). Are there examples of monopolies which didn't have state support?