6 ms·
I cringe every time I hear the US president being described as the leader of the free world, as if there were 2 specific sides and USA were leading it and as if
by prmoustache 5y ago
I cringe every time I hear the US president being described as the leader of the free world, as if there were 2 specific sides and USA were leading it and as if USA was an advocate for freedom.
- 1_player 5y agoOr just the fact that whenever there is an alien invasion, worldwide apocalypse or destruction, the effort to rebuild always starts from the USA. Every time I watch any of those movies I think "I wonder how Europe is faring..."
- PaulAJ 5y agoUp until 1990 that was a reasonable approximation to the truth. The USA certainly had its issues, but in a comparison between the USA and the USSR there was no question about who the relatively good guys were. Since the USSR collapsed, and especially since 9/11, things have gotten a lot murkier.
- lenkite 5y agoYou are clearly American. American administrations preferred and supported third-world tyrants during the Cold War over functional democracies since the former could be easily controlled. This is extensively documented and even admitted by several ex-DC head honchos. Public messaging by POTUS for national consumption is very different from actions on the ground.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoIf the US ever had good guy status, it's because of the principles it was founded upon. I'm not even sure up to which point those principles stood. Certainly not as late as the 90s. The second world war seems to have been the major turning point.
- goodpoint 5y ago> but in a comparison between the USA and the USSR That's a false dichotomy if I ever seen one.
- teawrecks 5y agoIt's literally a dichotomy by definition. If I say "in a comparison between chocolate and vanilla" I'm literally comparing those two specific flavors. To tell me it's a false dichotomy is silly.
- goodpoint 5y agoNo it's a false dichotomy because you are using the behavior of USSR as an excuse to give USA a pass. There's a reason why "I'm not as bad as <other person>" is not an acceptable legal defense.
- mrVentures 5y agoI guess they are saying that there are other options. So for example if I asked you "what is your favorite ice cream flavor, vanilla or chocolate?" you might respond to me with "that's a false dichotomy, there are more than two ice cream flavors, my favorite is banana which you have not listed as an option". At least that is my understanding of the context.
- freyr 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpower
- pjc50 5y agoThat was the dichotomy everyone had to deal with back in the day. Trying to be "unaligned" merely got you interference from both sides, with the possible exception of Switzerland.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoThe "good guys": - Guatemalan genocide - Operation Condor - Mass sterilization in Puerto Rico - Panama as a country - Arming the Taliban - And more... I think both governments had really shady people and cannot be characterized as "good".
- awestroke 5y agoReally? Good guys? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r... I especially like the US-created Contras in Nicaragua - actual terrorists. Just a massive history of interfering with democracies with the sole aim for furthering the economic goals of the US.
- cycomanic 5y agoI seriously challenge you to read up on the history of the Latin Americas or many African nations. The "leader of the free world" was installing and supporting fascist dictatorships left right and center, who killed thousands of people in their torture chambers (often using CIA resources). It's correct that the US was generally better to its own people (unless you were black of course), but it certainly wasn't a beacon of freedom to the world.
- antman 5y agoI assume you are American? As resident of one of the dozens of countries that suffered US led coups our opinions differ. The US has influenced with undemocratic methods a lot more countries than the USSR even before the 90s. Just compare Europe and US sphere influence (Latin America and Africa) with USSR sphere of influence (Eastern Europe and Caucasian) Also look what happened Foreign interventions in the USSR sphere of influence for Freedom (Syria, Libya and Yugoslavia, Former USSR naval bases in the Mediterranean) those were rebellions against dictatorships. All the others are insurgencies against democracies.
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoThe leader of a region of influence yes. “Good guy” “Free world” - relative on perspective and highly subjectively US POV
- avgcorrection 5y agoIs that how one reads history? Whether the Mongolian Empire or the Khwarazmian Empire were the “relatively good guys”? This is a child’s way of seeing the world.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s only possible with an extremely euro centric world view. If you were to focus on say, South America, you would’ve come to the exact opposite conclusion.
- fsloth 5y agoUSA is an advocate of very specific stability. "Free world" is a hyperbolic but US is still a huge global power. In cold war it was obvious there were two sides, and the other was obviously more free than the other. Go ask for example Estonians, Lithuanians or Latvians who they enjoyed the yoke of the USSR. Now, as China is becoming an ever more stronger player, we again see that there are two sides arising. While party lacks expansive ambitions in the traditional sense of landborders (except for Taiwan), they would very much like everyone to kotow to the party. We are in a world where democracies are in decline and autocracies are in the rise. USA is still the biggest democracy. Leader of the free world? It's hyperbolic, but not _obviously totally wrong_. This is not to say we are in some sort of manichean conflict world were one side is good and one is evil, or that US is good and the autocrats are evil. US is obviously a state actor that acts in it's own benefit and in the benefit of it's elites and so on, and these actions sometimes are very bad for civilians.
- callmeal 5y ago>In cold war it was obvious there were two sides Um, no. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement
- fsloth 5y agoThe article is pretty obvious about the fact that the "Non-Aligned" movement was in fact closely aligned with USSR "many of the Non-Aligned Movement's members were actually quite closely aligned with China or the Soviet Union"
- cycomanic 5y ago> USA is an advocate of very specific stability. "Free world" is a hyperbolic but US is still a huge global power. > In cold war it was obvious there were two sides, and the other was obviously more free than the other. Go ask for example Estonians, Lithuanians or Latvians who they enjoyed the yoke of the USSR. You could also ask a Guatemalan how they enjoyed living under the US installed military dictatorships (which came out of a US supported coup after democratic elections resulted in a win for the left). Things are by far not as clear cut. Both blocks supported atrocious regimes if it was in their economic interests and worked against "the other side". That we largely only hear about one side shows how well the propaganda was/is working.
- bambax 5y ago"Freedom" in American parlance is like "Truth" in Roman Catholic lingo.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThis was an unnecessarily devisive comment.
- Tostino 5y agoI mean its not wrong, Americans themselves hardly agree on the definition of freedom any more.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThere is no need to attack people’s religion.