4 ms·
I was nodding along until i reached: >Yes, even the bane of Darwin’s faith—the humble ichneumon wasp that lays its maggots inside the living bodies of caterpil
by bawolff 5y ago
I was nodding along until i reached:
>Yes, even the bane of Darwin’s faith—the humble ichneumon wasp that lays its maggots inside the living bodies of caterpillars to eat them from the inside and burst out on maturity like some alien xenomorph—is a beautiful creature with a sacred task. Like many parasites, its role in the great chain of being is to test the health and defenses of its caterpillar host population. Its predation weeds out the sickly, preventing the much uglier injustice of collective weakness and disease, and spurring the evolution of stronger and even more beautiful life. Even fearsome Nemesis, born from chaos via night and darkness, is ultimately the hand of God and the minister of justice. Even the supposed exceptions to justice prove its rule.
Which sounds like a self-indulgent justification to hurt others for your own gain while still being able to sleep at night.
- hsn915 5y ago> justification to hurt others for your own gain You're jumping into conclusions. His sentiment is better understood in terms of the balance of nature. He posted this on his Twitter a while back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q The video is titled "How Wolves Change Rivers". "When wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park in the United States after being absent nearly 70 years, the most remarkable "trophic cascade" occurred." As the video explains, unchecked herboviore species has caused a lot of damage to the environment, grazing much of the vegetation. The introduction of wolves radically changed the behavior of the prey species and they start avoiding certain places like valleys where they can easily be trapped. This allowed the vegetation to regenerate and trees started to grow. This resulted in birds moving in. Beavers started to increase, and the dams they built provided habitat for a bunch of other species of animals. And so on and so forth. The regeneration of the vegetation provided stability to the banks of the rivers so they collapsed less often.
- bawolff 5y agoI'm not disputing the ecological affects of predation. I'm disputing its use/applicability as a rhetorical device to further an argument about how to live a "good life". After all, this isn't an essay on ecology. This paragraph wasn't simply added because ecology is cool. It was added to further an argument.
- someguydave 5y agoNo, he is offering an idea to square a good and loving God with the horrors we see in life. This is known as a theodicy.
- srcreigh 5y agoYep. We could see the exploding callerpillars as being each one of our own unworthy pursuits. They blow up and we do better stuff instead.
- mlatu 5y agomore like failed enterprise attempts from people for whom that attempt was the only really viable way at getting out of wage-slavedom. or, just the exploited wage slaves at their EOL.
- bawolff 5y agoHow is that a counter argument to what i said? The best way to fix the problem of evil is to say that the evil has a higher noble purpose and thus is justified. That applies just as much to man as it does to the divine, and has been how the majority of evil acts in the world get justified. Giving it a fancy name just means it has a fancy name. It doesn't change the content of the idea.
- mlatu 5y ago> Which sounds like a self-indulgent justification to hurt others for your own gain while still being able to sleep at night. more like an excuse for the rampant exploitation of humans in precarious situations for gig or click work