3 ms·
And yet another non logarithmic graph of money. I'm really surprised to see such ignorance on The Economist. People who write about money for a living should k
by ars 15y ago
And yet another non logarithmic graph of money.
I'm really surprised to see such ignorance on The Economist. People who write about money for a living should know better.
- chime 15y agoThe scale is % of economic output and years lived. Assuming the output is inflation adjusted, why would you prefer the scale to be logarithmic?
- joshuamerrill 15y agoAgreed, since economic output is measured in 1990 Dollars, there's no need for a logarithmic scale here.
- ars 15y agoBecause economic output always builds on previous output. That is the definition of an exponential function, and to reverse those effects you need to take the log. It's easy to see this - just look at the early years, and notice the curve - it's an almost exact exponential curve. Graphing an exponential curve teaches you very little about the underlying data.
- GavinB 15y agoA logarithmic view would be great for showing when the population and output stalled or increased faster, but the purpose of this graph is to show that the fact that the increase is dramatically exponential, and at what point in the curve we are right now. Ideally both would be shown--but just showing the log graph would be misleading in this context.
- doyoulikeworms 15y agoI agree. I think that the point of this graph is to convey exponential growth, and simply that. It's not meant to be used "seriously," which'd make a logarithmic graph more suitable.
- hammock 15y agoArs is correct on this one (and also resdirector, the topvoted comment right now)- the issue is not money inflation, it's the simple fact that compounding growth will be exponential, always. So if your point is to show that growth rates increased in recent centuries, then you need to show growth rates, or show this but using a log scale.
- ca98am79 15y agoWhy should it be logarithmic?
- msellout 15y agoLogarithmic scale would better show the percent change of population in the early years. Using linear scale hides the movement of the early years because the 20th century's magnitude is so great that the previous centuries look identical to each other. It's more dramatic this way, but perhaps misleading.
- yxhuvud 15y agoBut that is the point of the graph - to show the ratio of history that has happened has happened recently. Or in other words, the point is not to show the growth patterns, but to show the nominal value.
- _delirium 15y agoI think that's where it's wrong, though; imo, "history" is better identified with the percent change, not with the nominal value. If someone improved some technology by 10% in 1850, and someone else improved it by another 10% in 1950, I'd call those historically equivalent contributions.