3 ms·
I'm quite confused by your examples. * terrain data: if that map were scanned into digital form, would it be less useful? If it were in digital form to begin
by Groxx 15y ago
I'm quite confused by your examples.
* terrain data: if that map were scanned into digital form, would it be less useful? If it were in digital form to begin with, you could probably overlay others' data / have it calculate time for you. Is this worse?
* digital maps are far more likely to be up to date.
* terrain / vegetation: what if it were in an overlay? Or, going the Flickr route, how about geotagged photos appearing where they were taken? If a paper map has the info, so can a digital one.
* big 3D object: Google Earth? Though, granted, it's a 2D projection - there are intrinsic disadvantages there.
* GPS / guided routes: well yeah, route-finding is hard, building numbers aren't 1:1 with their location, and GPS often isn't high-enough resolution to really know where you are. But what about the map aspect in a city? My iThing shows me road and structure data that's far more detailed and up-to-date than any map you can purchase and reasonably keep with you, and tells me about accidents / construction in bigger cities, accurate to the hour or better.
So, the only real reasons being... bigger is better, and 3D is great (but immobile)? And battery life and durability, of course, though they weren't listed.
I would find it extremely likely that you can't find digital maps with the same information as paper ones you can buy - I still need to go to the DMV to do some things, for no real, rational reason. Such is the world. But that's not intrinsic to the medium, it's merely a consequence of it being newer. Less available doesn't count, that attribute will reverse itself in time. What is it about digital that you find less effective?
- bootload 15y ago"... What is it about digital that you find less effective? ..." @Groxx simple, KISS. I'm not sure you go the kind of places I do. I need reliability not technology. 'Carry nothing new' is a motto that saves you from potential equipment failure. The argument you are giving is about ideal format. Mine is about reliability of use in the field. I'm more concerned about that hill I have to traverse on foot than finding "Joe's diner" or the cheapest alternative place to eat while driving a car. "... digital maps are far more likely to be up to date. ..." Agreed here cf: the digital examples I gave. Digital maps for display (phones, pda's, GPS) are really suited for showing directions from A to B & "thematic" layers of information that changes often, using the the cadastre & topography to define location. Thematic information changes often. The cadastre less often. The topography very little.