4 ms·
> The use of the WhatsApp, Signal and Telegram messenger services for military purposes in the Swiss armed forces is to be banned. Key part being "for military
by paxys 5y ago
> The use of the WhatsApp, Signal and Telegram messenger services for military purposes in the Swiss armed forces is to be banned.
Key part being "for military purposes". To me it is bizarre that these apps were being used in the first place. Does a national military really not have better/more secure ways to communicate internally than off-the-shelf messaging apps?
- siva7 5y agoNot everyone has billions like the US mil to throw at
- paxys 5y agoThey quite literally do. Their annual defense budget is $5B+. "Switzerland to Spend $2.5 Billion in Military Upgrades" (https://www.thedefensepost.com/2021/06/15/switzerland-invests-military-upgrades/ https://www.thedefensepost.com/2021/06/15/switzerland-invest...). Just last year they allocated $284 million towards "command and communication systems". You can build a hundred Whatsapps from scratch with that money. Where exactly did it all go?
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Where exactly did it all go? On hardened physical crypto radios I presume - rather than on consumer-grade apps.
- fullstop 5y agoOr, more likely, watches.
- guerrilla 5y agoSo, two to three orders of magnitude smaller than the US's budget depending on how you count... $5B is pocket change for the US military. Don't be pedantic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pacbard 5y agoI wonder if it's because of the quirky Swiss military setup where evertyone is basically enlisted as a reservist. I would imagine that the local village will have monthly drills and that they have to organize them somehow. Using WhatsApp/Telegram/Signal might be useful for them as they might already use them for other purposes and everyone has it installed. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_Switzerland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_Switzerland
- jeffrallen 5y agoNo, it's a real army with normal bureaucracy, not a village militia. You get your orders for your once a year repetition course about 3 months before, then show them to your HR department, who arranges for you to have paid time off, paid by the unemployment insurance or something. Then you go do it and come back to work. Your colleagues pick up your tasks while you are gone because you'll do the same for them later (and good teams value cross training anyway). Source: I was a team lead on a team with active Swiss army soldiers. While you are doing exercises, you have access to all the normal army comms stuff, including presumably encrypted digital HF radio for voice and data, satellite days, VHF radios, etc. This order is saying, "don't use commercial products, use the military comms systems we give you". Kind of too bad they didn't give an exception for Signal though... :)
- acoard 5y agoI love Signal and use it as my only messenger, but there's no guarantee the server side code is as secure as they say. For a private citizen like myself it certainly looks secure enough (eg in their warrant responses), but I wouldn't want a state to bet it's security on Signal's honesty.
- jeffrallen 5y agoThe promise of end to end encryption is that even if the server side put what it sees of your messages on a billboard in Times Square, nothing bad would happen.
- systemvoltage 5y agoI’m sure they have encrypted radio channels but P2P comms for non-war situation without having to pull out a 200 watt radio is probably lacking.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI don't know if there's some misunderstanding here - they weren't (I presume) using these apps for tactical comms. They're used for basic office and social messaging. Things like 'are you in tomorrow?' that you might send by clear phone call or civilian email anyway. The Swiss army of course have a full suite of encrypted tactical and operational UHF, VHF, HF, TacSat, etc.
- pas 5y agoSo what's the difference between a civilian email and Signal?
- Jtsummers 5y agoPresumably civilian email use for official communications is either less significant than Signal/WhatsApp/Telegram, or an official policy against civilian email use already exists and this is a clarification/extension of that policy.
- dathinab 5y agoAlso people tend to be more "chatty" on messengers and tend to think less what they write, hence much more chance of an accidental inclusion of sensitive information.
- jack_riminton 5y agoSpeaking from experience of the British Army, these are used mainly for admin stuff within sub units in barracks. eg. A Sergeant wants his soldiers to parade at 08:00 tomorrow Whereas these would never (usually) be used 'in the field'
- londons_explore 5y agoI worry that this 'admin stuff' can actually leak quite a lot of information. For example, to an adversary able to see the direct one to one social messages between a platoon of soldiers can probably easily figure out social dynamics, who might be most easily bribed, etc.
- aaomidi 5y agoThey can do that by looking at their public Facebook and Twitter lol
- dathinab 5y ago> worry that this 'admin stuff' can actually leak quite a lot of information. Hence why they put a limit on the usable chat systems. The worry also should extend to private conversations between to military members. But you can't really or them all the time to use military controlled apps, that in practice just doesn't work out. So limiting them to commercial but reasonable secure solutions which are under a local jurisdiction is a reasonable good solution. A public accessible Swiss military payed Signal fork probably would be an better solution tbh., but Threema isn't bad either. Just not quite as good as Signal.
- jack_riminton 5y agoWhilst I agree with you on principle the thought of an adversary combing data in order to bribe Private Bloggs of the Loamshire Rifles is comical
- throw0101a 5y ago> Whereas these would never (usually) be used 'in the field' You don't want people to get into bad habits.
- mrtksn 5y agoWell, WhatsApp is famously used by politicians all over the world. I would guess that the military do have secure encrypted means of communications but these are probably to be used at actual military operation and are probably very inconvenient to use. On the other hand, it's very convenient to communicate with your social circle and professional using the same device even the same app. By military purposes they probably don't mean to message buddies to break the door during an operation, for this they will use proper military gear. However you can imagine military personel discussing military stuff on WhatsApp etc. Stuff like scheduling things, clarifying information, discussing classified stuff to form an opinion or make a decision.
- stilisstuk 5y agoThis is specifically for military communication https://www.dencrypt.dk/ https://www.dencrypt.dk/
- Darvon 5y agoNothing says secure like proprietary code maintained by some guy's privately owned limited liability corporation with 20 wageslaves labouring for him.
- gherkinnn 5y agoCasually available apps can be used on-base as well. A few years back, US bases could be spotted using a fitness trackers heat map: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracking-app-gives-away-location-of-secret-us-army-bases https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracki...
- dathinab 5y ago> secure ways to communicate internally than off-the-shelf messaging apps Some of the better of the shelf apps are as or more secure then many of the military internal developed solutions of many militaries. At lest when applied to use-cases outside of war zones and similar. I mean there are top of the line security experts all around the world directly and indirectly contributing to apps like Signal. On the other hand the amount of scrutiny a proprietary military app will receive is limited. But more important "for military purposes" includes a lot of situations you might not have considered. Like more or less all communication done between two active members of the military, even if of duty, as long as work content might pop up in the conversation. Or like they sending a member on break a message that due to weather forecast there is a good chance they will have to interrupt your brake for helping with "disaster relive" (which can e.g. include removing snow after some unusual heavy snow fall, or helping with cleanup after a avalanche). To just name some situations.