9 ms·
Swiss army restricts use of messenger apps for military purposes
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vanusa 5y ago[flagged] misleading title
- chrisseaton 5y agoIs the Army giving everyone a personal device to run Threema on? That's why people use WhatsApp - because people already have it on their phones. If the Army wants people to install a special app people are likely to ask them to provide the device.
- AdrianB1 5y agoI think it's more of "if you want to use such an app on your own phone while doing military service, you are allowed to use only X". Same situation exists in companies where BYOD policies have limitations.
- feupan 5y agoI don’t think that’s common at all outside the US. I’d argue that even suggesting that would get you blank stares for its absurdity. I don’t think anyone has been expecting a paid-for device for the past two years just because to work you have to install Zoom, even in the US.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I don’t think anyone has been expecting a paid-for device for the past two years just because to work you have to install Zoom. Most employees have to buy their own work tech devices outside of the US?
- AdrianB1 5y agoTo some extent, yes. My employer is a big US-based company, but in my country (Romania) I bought my own phone, external monitors, mouse etc. If you are high ranking or well connected you get some of these via internal IT supply system, but the quality is very basic, ex. they expect developers to work on $125 monitors - what the fine art of magic can you do with that? Managers have iPhones paid by the company, company cars, etc. but most working people have to find a way to work on their own. There are companies that provide some budget for work equipment, but unless it is mandatory by law the budget and quality of equipment varies a lot, from good to terrible or none.
- feupan 5y agoIf you’re at the office no, but I suppose you only get a company phone if your job is to communicate.
- regularfry 5y agoZoom's not going anywhere near my personal devices. Nor is MS Teams, or any other communicator with work credentials. We (big employer in the UK) can order paid-for devices on the corporate purchasing system. It works out best for everyone: they can control the device, I can turn it off at the end of the day, and nobody has to see my reaction when they say "oh yeah, now we can remote-brick your personal phone."
- Sunspark 5y agoYes, always buy or use your erased previous device for applications that require work credentials. When WFH became more widespread at the office in 2020, the local mgmt team told everyone to enter all sorts of information into a spreadsheet like their IMEI number, etc. Then people discovered after the fact that their personal devices were now managed devices. Cue surprised faces. MDM rejects bootloader unlocked devices, so even if you have extra devices you might not be able to use them because of that or the OS version being too low to please them. A good alternative if available, is to use Citrix Receiver instead, it doesn't require MDM and doesn't require permissions. It does require an RSA keyfob.
- croes 5y agoI don't have WhatsApp on my phone, it not part of the Android standard apps.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI'm sure there's some corner cases, but every soldier I've ever interacted with already had it on their phone for personal use. That's how it's become so commonly used.
- jackdh 5y ago> The annual fees charged to Threema users will be paid by the army, but critics say there are no sanctions planned for army members who continue to use other messenger tools. That doesn't sound like they've banned it at all.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoSo the "killer feature" that the Swiss Army used to justify Threema over Signal and the others is that it's Swiss based and not US based like the others, not a technical feature that guarantees better proven security. I don't blame them one second for going local, but then if security and ownership of your comms is what you're after, why not set up your own Matrix server for comms for your military personnel like every European country (I think), and instead purchase Threema licenses? I feel this is basically a form of corporate sponsorship/handouts from the government/defense sector in disguise, to support a local champion (basically how the US defense sector propped up Silicon Valley in its inception).
- frabcus 5y agoIt’s a military reason. In the event of war you want complete control of comms systems for your military. This makes sense to me! I think it would be foolish of any army to use a comms system another country controls.
- Jtsummers 5y agoThere are multiple reasons, and that would be one of them. Another reason is legal/regulatory: Most government and military employees (especially in countries that at least want to have the appearance of opposing corruption) have specific record keeping requirements. If you use unofficial channels for official communications, you are almost certainly violating those rules and laws. "Where's lunch today?", not an issue. "Let's discuss these budget items and make a decision", that's an issue. I don't know Swiss laws and rules, but I'd be surprised if they permitted, say, coordination of movement of military assets (in country, peace time) via unofficial, unrecorded methods.
- cm2187 5y agoIf they run on iOS or Android, you'd better make sure the US isn't on the other side of that war.
- danuker 5y agoI see Threema does not require your phone number, but it wants you to download the App/Play Store version. Whereas with WhatsApp you can download the APK file from the site. This is not only identifies you through Google/Apple services, but is also fundamentally incompatible with software freedom, as few can audit the binaries they receive. Unless you build your own binaries from the open source project (which has its issue tracker disabled for the public), you are out of luck.
- speedgoose 5y agoI was wondering why Signal suggests a 6 digits passphrase by default. Even with a good key derivation algorithm, it’s trivial to brute force in a very short time.
- jjtheblunt 5y ago"trivial" means exactly what? I ask because it's not trivial to clone the memory of a phone and have a network of simulators capable of simultaneously enumerating each combination, to stave off slowed-next-attempt policies etc.
- tiagod 5y agoIt's trivial as long as there are companies selling one-click solutions to do it.
- White_Wolf 5y agoIf your budget is in the upper upper 5 digits range, it's trivial. If a serious attacker is set on getting your stuff, it's just a matter of time and money. It's down to how much the data is worth for the attacker.
- speedgoose 5y agoThe brute force is trivial once you got the data, no pass phrase would be as secure. I think in this case a for loop on a single laptop would be fast enough.
- jjtheblunt 5y agobut the os builds insert an increasing delay before allowing a next attempt. like the first iteration of the for loop runs at time 0, fails; second iteration gets to start 10 seconds later, fails; third iteration gets to start 1 minute later, fails; fourth iteration gets to start 1 hour later, fails; and so on.
- speedgoose 5y ago
- 1MachineElf 5y agoCongratulations to Threema[0][1] for getting the whole Swiss army to standardize on your software. [0] https://threema.ch/en https://threema.ch/en [1] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=threema https://hn.algolia.com/?q=threema
- andreasley 5y agoLet's hope this turns out better than with Omnisec. Omnisec AG was a swiss company with (hidden) ties to US intelligence services [1] that produced manipulated encryption devices. Switzerland's military was also using Omnisec hardware and I doubt they received the "proper" ones. [1] https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/second-swiss-firm-allegedly-sold-encrypted-spying-devices/46186432 https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/second-swiss-firm-allegedly-sol...
- paxys 5y ago> The use of the WhatsApp, Signal and Telegram messenger services for military purposes in the Swiss armed forces is to be banned. Key part being "for military purposes". To me it is bizarre that these apps were being used in the first place. Does a national military really not have better/more secure ways to communicate internally than off-the-shelf messaging apps?
- siva7 5y agoNot everyone has billions like the US mil to throw at
- paxys 5y agoThey quite literally do. Their annual defense budget is $5B+. "Switzerland to Spend $2.5 Billion in Military Upgrades" (https://www.thedefensepost.com/2021/06/15/switzerland-invests-military-upgrades/ https://www.thedefensepost.com/2021/06/15/switzerland-invest...). Just last year they allocated $284 million towards "command and communication systems". You can build a hundred Whatsapps from scratch with that money. Where exactly did it all go?
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Where exactly did it all go? On hardened physical crypto radios I presume - rather than on consumer-grade apps.
- fullstop 5y agoOr, more likely, watches.
- guerrilla 5y agoSo, two to three orders of magnitude smaller than the US's budget depending on how you count... $5B is pocket change for the US military. Don't be pedantic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- immmmmm 5y agoi'm swiss, our army is a joke, especially when it comes to IT. a 4+B CHF joke tho. while i support the use of swiss secure solutions for critical stuff, it should be noted our beautiful militia is mostly there for a reason: allow male teenagers to become men, namely 1) play with explosives, 2) get drunk and 3) loose their virginity with prostitutes. they will probably allow back these apps for military operations when they discover these are more secure than their proprietary communication systems. can't wait they get their F35..
- dgellow 5y agoYep, all of this is unfortunately true. The whole thing is a sad joke, both the militia and the professional army.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI thought the Swiss Army was extremely well-regarded? It has a good reputation in the UK. I worked with one of your Grenadiers once and he was very professional and competent.
- dgellow 5y agoIt's the same for almost everything associated with the country, what you see from the outside has very little to do with the actual thing. The country has been very good at developing the "swiss brand", generally speaking. In practice the swiss army is a giant live action role-play, where young males go to be paid for playing with firearms and be drunk together. Note that you can be very professional while larping, it's not contradictory.
- hocuspocus 5y agoThey've been trying to up their game since the 2016 cyber attacks, I know the army tried to hire top security and cryptography experts. I don't know if they're very successful though, the intersection of (Swiss citizen, PhD level in infosec, willing to work for the military) is probably fairly small.
- croes 5y agoAt the latest since Crypto AG, Switzerland can no longer be trusted.
- pier25 5y agoSo what are they using instead?
- dobin 5y agoOnly Threema is allowed now.
- rvz 5y agoAt least Threema doesn't require your phone number. Such a requirement is absolutely ridiculous as a sign in option. I also heard all three of these messengers WhatsApp [0], Signal [1] and Telegram [2] have a cryptocurrency projects too for their users. So now they are automatically involved in promoting ponzi scam-coins as well, which Threema has none of that. Great choice for the Swiss Army to use Threema then. [0] https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/9/22825766/whatsapp-novi-digital-payments-us-pilot-paxos-stablecoin https://www.theverge.com/2021/12/9/22825766/whatsapp-novi-di... [1] https://www.wired.com/story/signal-mobilecoin-cryptocurrency-payments/ https://www.wired.com/story/signal-mobilecoin-cryptocurrency... [2] https://cointelegraph.com/news/telegram-verified-payments-bot-to-accept-toncoin-cryptocurrency https://cointelegraph.com/news/telegram-verified-payments-bo...
- dgellow 5y agoI'm surprised anyone on this website would care about this information, the swiss army is quite meaningless and mostly driven by politics.
- zdw 5y agoBack in 2018, there was an article about fitness apps like Strava exposing secret military locations: https://www.wired.com/story/strava-heat-map-military-bases-fitness-trackers-privacy/ https://www.wired.com/story/strava-heat-map-military-bases-f...
- dobin 5y agoI dont think the army permits transferring confidential information via privately owned phones, or via foreign companies, before. And neither does it now. Note that we have mandatory military service. Every year thousands of new recruits will perform military service for around half a year. After that, they have to attend three weeks of military service yearly (refresher). This always requires organization; when to arrive in the barracks, equipment to bring, request for leave, corona updates etc. Also coordination at which McDonalds to stop at the freeway. Same for professional army members. They need to communicate somehow, without using super encrypted email or radios (schtichwort "fill guns", super). Military IT is also as you expect (old and cumbersome).
- cbfrench 5y agoGuess you could say the Swiss Army took the knife to them.
- betwixthewires 5y agoThis is fantastic. Switzerland needs to use something within its jurisdiction, threema is an excellent choice. The title is a bit misleading, at first glance it seems as if the military banned encrypted communications for soldiers' personal communication. No, this only applies to mile Gary communications, and is to allow swiss sovereignty over the services they use.
- yosito 5y agoThreema is now the "Swiss Army Knife" of chat apps.
- samwillis 5y agoI hope the UK Government/Parliament see this and also ban the use of WhatsApp, it seems everything for back room dealing to anonymous briefing of journalists happens via it. Every scandal over the last few years always seems to either start or end with screenshots of WhatsApp conversations.
- opan 5y agoMy first thought was "great, all those are proprietary* and centralized. maybe they'll use XMPP or Matrix", but I see people mentioning Threema. I'm not familiar with it. A glance at Wikipedia shows the protocol is MIT and the apps are AGPL, so that sounds good anyway. Signal may not exactly be proprietary, but they won't put it on F-Droid, so... Telegram has a free-ish client but not a server
- max_ 5y agoWhy isn't there an ergonomic & secure communications app?
- Krasnol 5y agoMeanwhile the German Bundeswehr went for Matrix: https://messenger.bwi.de/ https://messenger.bwi.de/
- dathinab 5y ago> WhatsApp, Signal and Telegram WhatsApp and Telegram I can understand but Signal is a bit strange, they probably could just have setup some way to have "Swiss army compiled" version of Signal which IMHO would be more safe then Threema. While I do use Threema and like it's decoupling from phone numbers it has problems including Salamander attacks on their group chats and a very easily DDOS able account creation system. Furthermore most other users I meet did for a long time not know about the importance of Threema Id backups, often until they switched phones and lost their Threema Id... Generally from what I can tell it _seems_ (i.e. speculation) to be developed from experienced software engineers, but missing some "full-on security experts/researchers(1)" and there is in my experience a subtle but for this kind of things important gap between a senior engineer with a lot of security expertise and a non-junior full-on security expert/researcher. (1): What I mean hear is a bit tricky to define. First security experts and researchers are not necessary the same then different people have different field of expertise and skill level, so just doing it full time isn't necessary enough.
- warner25 5y agoMost people are focusing on security in the comments, but I think that's missing a more important point. First, all developed-nation military forces have internal, "secure" tactical and strategic communication networks for classified (e.g. Secret, Top Secret) data. So something like WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, or Threema would only be used for unclassified, administrative communications as others have already mentioned. But there are still controls required for unclassified, administrative communications. Speaking as a US military officer who works in IT, we have to think about data ownership and retention for things like investigations and compliance with FOIA requests. It's impossible to do that if everyone is using personal accounts on communications services that we don't control. I'm not sure how much control the Swiss government can exert over Threema, but it's presumably more than they can control services hosted outside of their borders. This article from last summer explains why the US Defense Digital Service Director got in trouble for using the Signal app for official business: https://www.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/2021/06/defense-digital-service-director-used-signal-violation-pentagon-policy-ig-says/174879/ https://www.nextgov.com/cio-briefing/2021/06/defense-digital...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]