2 ms·
Well, neither Java, Common Lisp nor ALGOL60 support operator overloading, so there does seem to be a trend there. Common Lisp in fact, as most lisps, has no su
by tsimionescu 5y ago
Well, neither Java, Common Lisp nor ALGOL60 support operator overloading, so there does seem to be a trend there.
Common Lisp in fact, as most lisps, has no support for "operators" in the infix sense at all. If you have a need for a very algebra-heavy portion in your program (say, a linear algebra library), the best idea would be to define a DSL for that particular algebra - especially since this will give you much more control over efficient evaluation than using the built-in evaluation order.
A good example of the limitations of simplistic operator overloading is matrix algebra: A+B•C can be computed efficiently as a ternary operation, more efficiently than doing A+B then multiplying the result by C. Now of course, you can implement this in C++ by having operator+() return some kind of matrix_addition object, and then defining the efficient operations in operator*(matrix_addition, matrix) etc, but that is much more roundabout than defining a simple addAndMul(A,B,C), or an explicit optimizing DSL.
- lispm 5y agoThere are reader macros which provide a more math-like notation. Those are translating the math syntax into Lisp s-expressions at read-time.
- tsimionescu 5y agoYes, that's the DSL concept I was talking about.