3 ms·
But the law isn't about cookies, it's about tracking and making sure you, the user, know you are being tracked. The poor UX is malicious compliance and seems to
by sofixa 5y ago
But the law isn't about cookies, it's about tracking and making sure you, the user, know you are being tracked. The poor UX is malicious compliance and seems to be working since so many people complaining about cookie banners and the law but not companies tracking you, the actual bad guys.
- baby 5y agoIt doesn’t matter what the law is about, what matters are the actual consequences and the impact that the law has had. So far it has had quite a negative impact for users. I really don’t see how this was a win for anyone.
- pull_my_finger 5y agoI wonder if you're playing Devil's advocate or you really are defending this.. They could skip the "burden" users face by just not using so many dang tracking cookies. If you want information about how your customers use the site, or what their interests are, you can just _ask_ and try to solicit feedback explicitly. Most of the people will likely decline, but that _should be_ their choice to do so. And providing feedback _should be_ opt-in, not opt-OUT.
- dmitriid 5y agoThe law: exists, and is quite unequivocal. Sites: implement things that are actually illegal under the law HN, en masse: the law is bad, how can you say it's good? EU has been very slow in going after websites, but I do hope they pick up the pace.
- Kstarek 5y agoEU has far overreached, I hope their declining relevancy hastens and their holier than thou attitude continues to aid it in doing so
- dmitriid 5y ago> EU has far overreached How exactly did it overreach? Every country in Europe had data protection laws prior to GDPR. All these shitty sites ignored them. So EU created a single law. If you want to sell people's data without their consent, go <expletive deleted>. The US will eventually have similar laws as well (CCPA is one if them)
- baby 5y ago
- dmitriid 5y ago10 years in Sweden, and counting.
- baby 5y agoMaybe you have the opposite problem then, get out for a trip and see how much better browsing the web is
- dmitriid 5y agoYou have any arguments beyond ad hominem? This law exposes a very serious problem: even sites like Oracle's news blog or Volvo's corporate site, or British Airways's profile pages are selling your data to hundreds of advertisers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- qwertox 5y agoThe consequences only highlight the problem. We're currently in the first stage in a transition towards allowing the end user to express their wishes about tracking which then companies need to respect. It only shows how disrespectful almost all companies are by attempting to shape the end users opinion on this law by attacking them with dark patterns. If France is now expecting companies to equalize the opt-in and the opt-out behavior, they're essentially attacking these dark patterns, which is very welcome by almost all end users. I hope that there will come a point in time when I can go into the settings of my browser, tell it what the default behavior (answer) should be and possibly even express interests in certain ad categories to whitelist them, like "biking". It would be a granular "Do Not Track" option which must be respected by the website.
- bhk 5y ago> But the law isn't about cookies EU law very much is about cookies. > ... the ePrivacy Directive (EPD) has become known as the “cookie law” since its most notable effect was the proliferation of cookie consent pop-ups after it was passed. > Strictly necessary cookies — These cookies are essential for you to browse the website and use its features, such as accessing secure areas of the site. Cookies that allow web shops to hold your items in your cart while you are shopping online are an example of strictly necessary cookies. These cookies will generally be first-party session cookies. While it is not required to obtain consent for these cookies, what they do and why they are necessary should be explained to the user. > However, properly informing your users about the cookies your site is using and, when necessary, receiving their consent will keep your users happy and keep you GDPR-compliant. https://gdpr.eu/cookies/ https://gdpr.eu/cookies/