3 ms·
>that modern life for most of us is incomparably better than the lives most of us had in the past. It is, if we measure it against the average (or even worst)
by coldtea 5y ago
>that modern life for most of us is incomparably better than the lives most of us had in the past.
It is, if we measure it against the average (or even worst) of the past (and go quite far back), and also include things like slavery, etc. as if they are non-separable parts of the past, and not something we could have skipped even in the past (and many places did).
>My kids are 17/18 now, while I was the same age back in the early 80s. There's no comparison. The quality of life available on even a modest salary nowadays is far, far better.
Is it? I'd take the 60's or 80's any day - less rat racy, easier employment, more value for your money, more optimism, less wage inequality, better off middle class, less surveillance, less bureucracy, more relaxed life, and so on. Also a better top-10 and nicer looking cars. And I (and perhaps others) would also gladly take fewer modern technology items over a simpler, more sustainable lifestyle.
I don't consider things like some improved smart fridge, or smart bulbs, or a car GPS and mobile phone much of a quality of life improvement. If anything, some of those are net negatives.
And things that have been worse, e.g. seggregation, they were not "1960s didn't have advance technology to avoid that", they're just cultural choices. We often mix these two ups, like we couldn't have, say, 1980 living, technology, etc. AND gay rights.
- yazantapuz 5y agoWell, if I had been born in the 60's i will not have survived my cancer diagnosis.
- ch4s3 5y ago> easier employment Unemployment ranged from 5.40% to 10.4% in the 80s and is 4.2% now. Only the last few yeas of the 60s had lower unemployment than 2021. In 1960 people spend 24% of their income on food, vs 8.6% today. And for most Americans the food was FAR worse in 1960s, cold chain and logistics improvements mean that average Americans have access regularly to foods that were luxuries in 1980. > nicer looking cars Those cars were death traps. There were twice as many fatalities per 100k Americans in 1960 vs today with fewer people driving fewer miles per capita. > more sustainable lifestyle The US of the 60s and 70s was so choked by smog and industrial pollution that Nixon created the EPA. Cars now get 2x the mpg vs 1960. Forrest coverage was lower, and numerous species that have now recovered were going extinct, like the bald eagle. > better off middle class The middle class wasn't better off, it was larger. The poverty rate in 2017 was half of what it was in 1960. And since 1960 many families have moved from the middle income quintile to one of the top quintiles. The middle class in the US didn't disappear into poverty, most of it just became more wealthy. The 1960s sucked, there was political upheaval, the Cold War, the Cuban Missile crisis, global spanning totalitarianism, frequent political assassinations, Jim Crow, and on and on.
- coldtea 5y ago>Unemployment ranged from 5.40% to 10.4% in the 80s and is 4.2% now. That's because of an increasing number of magic tricks the neoliberal governments (which includes both Rep and Dem, and any major party in Europe on the last 30+ years) have agreed on to make it appear so. Makes them appear as having done their job (no pun intended). Things like not counting people giving up on job hunting, and especially avoiding any qualitative comparison, and counting any kind of shitty precarious non-job as a job. Hell, if it isn't the case already, I'm pretty sure "Uber Driver" and "Amazon Mechanical Turk signee" will also sure count towards reduced unemployment. >The US of the 60s and 70s was so choked by smog and industrial pollution Yes. And still the US had less CO2 production, less plastic waste, and more sustainable lifestyle. You're taking a by-product of 1970s car exhausts as if it's a permanent given. We could go back to 1960 levels CO2 production, less consumption (e.g. no fast fashion, less fast food) and so on. And we could do it without giving up modern exhausts, hybrids, and electric cars. >Forrest coverage was lower, and numerous species that have now recovered were going extinct, like the bald eagle. 2022 really doesn't want to start an argument about extinguished species with the 1960s. >The 1960s sucked Not the experience of most who lived through them and herald them as a great age, or even many who didn't live them, and still consider them so. >there was political upheaval Far better, more progressive, and forward looking political upheaval than in the last 10 years... >the Cold War, the Cuban Missile crisis, global spanning totalitarianism, frequent political assassinations So, business as usual. Though I'm not sure what bearing exactly the have in this conversation. We can have the positive things I've mentioned about the 60s (which were about levels of employment, consumption, sustainability, etc.) without the "cuban missile crisis" and "frequent political assassination" and so on. Those are historical incidents. The things I pointed at are things we can adopt or not. >Jim Crow, and on and on. The 60s was the era that got rid of the last of Jim Crow laws.
- ch4s3 5y ago> That's because of an increasing number of magic tricks the neoliberal governments The BLS has been measuring the unemployment rate the same way since 1940. > Yes. And still the US had less CO2 production, less plastic waste, and more sustainable lifestyle. You're taking a by-product of 1970s car exhausts as if it's a permanent given. The was more of almost every type of type of non C02 industrial pollutant. There was acid rain, and we were punching a hole in the ozone with refrigerants. Pesticides in use then were far more toxic to people and wildlife. Asbestos was everywhere, and lead was in everything. We could certainly consume fewer disposable things, but the tradeoff is that being poor today affords people a far higher material standard of living than in 1960 by literally any metric. > Yes. And still the US had less CO2 production This is almost entirely solvable over the next few decades. > 2022 really doesn't want to start an argument about extinguished species with the 1960s. You could and you'd find that numerous large charismatic species on the verge of extinction by the mid 70s have recovered in much of the world. The US has become so rich that we're re-wilding and re-introducing displaced species. The rest of the world could follow. > Far better, more progressive, and forward looking political upheaval than in the last 10 years... We started a drug war and the expansion of the carceral state in the late 60s[1]. MLK, JFK, RFK, and Malcom X were all assassinated so I wouldn't call that progressive upheaval. And the progressive upheaval caused by the likes of The Weather Underground or the SLA is hardly impressive. > Those are historical incidents Everyone living under the constant threat of nuclear holocaust was kind of a wer blanket. > The 60s was the era that got rid of the last of Jim Crow laws. By the end, and replaced it with a drug war. In the 60s crime was higher, material wealth was less plentiful, more people lived in poverty, life expectancy was shorter, and most people in society had few options. Localized environmental pollution was worse. Cars were far less safe, and mortality by all causes was higher. > Not the experience of most who lived through them and herald them as a great age Nostalgia does that to people, but basically all objective measures of life quality were worse. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Rise-Warrior-Cop-Militarization-Americas/dp/1610394577 https://www.amazon.com/Rise-Warrior-Cop-Militarization-Ameri...
- erosenbe0 5y agoNo way I want my loved ones to live without balloon angioplasty and statins from the last 35 years. Men in their 30s and 40s commonly having debilitating heart attacks with few options? No thanks. Also the 1960s was full of smoky offices and literal poison leaded gas fumes in everyone's blood stream. Gross
- SamReidHughes 5y agoDespite that, people were healthier day-to-day. Less obesity.