3 ms·
The “lunch will be a pill” stuff is always funny to me. There’s a major volume issue unless you’re gonna have me eat chunks of uranium or neutron star or someth
by ceejayoz 5y ago
The “lunch will be a pill” stuff is always funny to me. There’s a major volume issue unless you’re gonna have me eat chunks of uranium or neutron star or something.
- datavirtue 5y agoI thought it was goofy until I remembered that some people eat pills for lunch.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThere's Soylent and similar meal replacements, but that's a diet shake for people who try to min-max their life for some reason.
- galangalalgol 5y agoI was excited about the kickstarter because while a recovering alcoholic can completely stop using alcohol, a food addict always has to eat a little. Something bland, and quick I didn't think about was a plus. But afyer the Kickstarter they replaced the fish oil with polyunsaturated vegetable oil in powder form and dropped the rice protein content for more carbs. My triglycerides shot through the roof after the first few months of that recipe.
- krupan 5y agoYou could try keto chow. They started with the Soylent recipe and made it carb free (if you don't count fiber as carbs). https://www.ketochow.xyz/ https://www.ketochow.xyz/
- galangalalgol 5y agoI'm not against carbs, I just like macro ratios more like the earlier versions. Lots of carbs and polyunsaturated oils are in the literature as triglyceride boosters. If they offered a version with the fish oil back in and the old protein ratios I'd be interested, especially if the replaced the rice protein with the collagen or fish meal from the bait fish the oil came from. At least as sustainable as giant fields of rice and safflower and probably lower in heavy metals too. Rice sucks up the cadmium.
- krupan 5y agoThere are several other Soylent mods out there. Super Body Fuel, Huel, and Tsogo are a few others I tried. Not a drink, but Meal Squares and Greenbelly Meals are a similar idea too. No idea if any of them meet your needs. I think there was a website that had a huge list of meal replacements. (Edit typo fix)
- 2snakes 5y agoJust replacing one meal like breakfast with Soylent is probably preferred over replacing 3-4.
- krono 5y agoThinking outside the box, that pill could be part of a more involved system where it triggers the release of nutrition that was consumed earlier. It doesn't have to be a completely self-contained solution.
- scrollaway 5y agoI love where your head's at. Project: Chipmunk. Stuff those cheeks :)
- mc32 5y agoIf NASA[1] could have this, they would do this. They'd prefer it if they could give their *nauts pill-like nutrition delivery systems. [1] Also armed forced with deployed troops would love this too as it makes food logistics much easier.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe closest we can get volume-wise is a cup of olive oil for about 2k calories. Stuffing any more calories into the same volume would require using materials we can't currently digest. (NASA does not like the side-effects of an all-oil diet on space toilets, I suspect.)
- awhitby 5y agoThis was my initial reaction too: it doesn't seem to pass basic conservation of mass. But actually how much mass must you necessarily lose to stay alive each day? Most of it is probably water, so if we allow "four pills plus as much water" at a meal then it's harder to rule out the pill diet. Maybe a better way to bound it: apparently we exhale around 1 kg of CO2 each day, which has 370g of carbon in it so unless we can radically reengineer our metabolism I guess you need a minimum of 370g daily to maintain carbon levels. 370g / 3 meals / 4 pills = 30g per pill. Even with the density of diamond that would be (picking a convenient rough number) 8 cm3 or 2x2x2cm. Which is... a hard pill to swallow. Maybe not impossible though.
- Eduard 5y ago370g of carbon required per day? That can't be. Even with a pure fat-based diet, 370g of fat (9 kcal/g) equals 3330 kcal daily - way too high for the sedentary HN requirement of 2000 kcal. With 2000 kcal, three meals with four pills equals twelve lard pills, each in a squishy 2.7cm cube format, easy to swallow. ;-)