4 ms·
'"Tokens align network participants to work together toward a common goal — the growth of the network and the appreciation of the token." That's great if what y
by Animats 5y ago
'"Tokens align network participants to work together toward a common goal — the growth of the network and the appreciation of the token." That's great if what you're trying to do is create an ecosystem of tokens that appreciate in value all the time. What percentage of systems can be modeled that way?'
That's the problem. "An ecosystem of tokens that appreciate in value all the time". The perpetual motion machine of finance.
Bitcoin has actually been able to pull this off, more or less. Etherium, maybe. The rest, not so much.
The NFT thing is winding down. NFTs are basically Axie Infinity, OpenSea, and the little guys. Axie Infinity is crashing. SLP is down to $0.02, from $0.35 at peak a few months ago.
OpenSea is hard to measure. There's wash trading to pump up prices.[1] NFTs have no overall market price. NFT markets stall, rather than crashing - high asking prices, no sales. There's a lot of that on OpenSea. "So far, most new NFT collectors on the secondary market have yet to recoup the costs of their purchases"[2] In other words, the issuer makes money, but the suckers who buy NFTs lose. Many of them don't realize they've lost. Someday they will find out, when they try to liquidate their Bored Ape Yacht Club collection.
I kind of liked the idea of NFTs as part of an asset portability system for virtual worlds. Goldman Sachs even endorsed that. I was thinking of this for items in the US$1 - US$100 range, like game items. The transaction costs would be too high if it took a blockchain transaction to walk through a portal, even for the cheap blockchains.
Some big part of all this is probably going to come apart in 2021. Definitely Axie Infinity. Maybe Tether.
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/15/22676075/opensea-insider-information-nft-trading-nate-chastain https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/15/22676075/opensea-insider-...
[2] https://www.ft.com/content/e95f5ac2-0476-41f4-abd4-8a99faa7737d https://www.ft.com/content/e95f5ac2-0476-41f4-abd4-8a99faa77...
- mgaunard 5y agoIsn't money supposed to depreciate over time rather than appreciate?
- Animats 5y agoDepends. Some gold seller used to advertise that in 1400 AD an ounce of gold would buy two good suits, and today it will buy about two good suits.
- lukeramsden 5y agoThat's the central bank narrative, whether its a good thing or not I think is still up for debate. Regardless, this can still be done with crypto (in fact, Ethereum is inflationary and not fixed cap like Bitcoin is), except that speculation and capital inflow still drastically outpace the inflation. Presumably one day an equilibrium will be reached.
- denismenace 5y agoWhether a certain amount of inflation is good or not, is definitely not up for debate. Nobody wants something that is a medium for value to become so valuable that you can't use it for its original purpose.
- celticninja 5y ago2021? That ship has sailed.
- Animats 5y agoOops. Meant 2022.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoUbisoft Quarts had 15 sales for 50$, total revenue: 745$ - https://objkt.com/collection/ubisoftquartz https://objkt.com/collection/ubisoftquartz And only 0.665 % earns money on OpenSea. Concentration of it is way less, you can just crawl the collections. 5 collections dominate all the rest and only the first 266 collections earned > 0 eth. The other 40 k. earned 0 eth. It's obviously not a way for an artist to earn any money. https://pastebin.com/NyLMcs7c https://pastebin.com/NyLMcs7c Script to reproduce ( linqpad): http://share.linqpad.net/wkbrut.linq http://share.linqpad.net/wkbrut.linq Beyond the hype are the numbers :)! Edit: Didn't contain the script.
- iskander 5y agoThat number seems off by a few orders of magnitude. I tried searching for familiar collections and couldn't find any of them: - Corruption(*s) - Bored Ape Yacht Club - Lonely Aliens Space Club - NFT Worlds You also have neither entries for the major Art Blocks series (Curated/Playground/Factory) nor any of the hundreds of individual artist collections contained in them. So, I think your crawl might be off. Additionally, individual artists tend to not use OpenSea but instead use Rarible, Foundation, and SuperRare (or skip ethereum altogether and use something on Tezos like fxhash).
- NicoJuicy 5y agoIt's not crawling. Perhaps in their api. You can just check it, since it's an aggregation of their collection endpoint. OpenSea is still the biggest NFT market and had an api, that's why I checked their api. Edit: sorry, the linqpad link was to pastebin instead of the source. Adjusted it
- Animats 5y agoWhat does "market cap" mean here? The sum of asking prices? That's meaningless. You can put any asking price you want on something, and through a wash sale, even put it on the blockchain.
- iskander 5y ago>I kind of liked the idea of NFTs as part of an asset portability system for virtual worlds. Goldman Sachs even endorsed that. I was thinking of this for items in the US$1 - US$100 range, like game items. The transaction costs would be too high if it took a blockchain transaction to walk through a portal, even for the cheap blockchains. This is theoretically possible on Zero Knowledge rollup L2s (two strongest contenders are zkSync and StarkNet) if they achieve sufficient scale but definitely wouldn't work on monolithic chains (not even relatively cheap ones).
- Animats 5y agotheoretically possible zkSync says they don't have their test net for smart contracts up yet. StarkNet is in alpha. For this problem, it's OK if change commit verification takes a while, as long as it's cheap. If you move your no-copy NFT from grid A to grid B, grid B can verify that you own it, even though the current state is on grid A, and let you show it on grid B. A slow check later by each grid can prevent persistent dual copies. It's like catching double spends later. It's consistent eventually. This is one of the things NFT proponents talk about - being able to move your truly-owned asset from one grid to another. However, so far there seem to be zero implementations. NFT land is tied up with make-money-fast right now. Potentially useful low-cost applications aren't getting done.
- iskander 5y agoSpeculation generates 99% of the noise in crypto but technology does keep moving forward. L2s were just whitepapers a few years ago, now there are multiple full featured optimistic rollup L2s (e.g. Arbitrum); zkRs, which are much more complex, are getting close. Lots of complex applications are now running on single-app StarkNet (e.g. derivatives platforms like dydx) and like you mentioned, the multi-app network is in alpha.