4 ms·
Disclaimer: happy Sublime Text 3 and 4 customer. I don’t really see the problem here? Like, ok, maybe you can be a bit upset that the app now asks you to upgra
by saagarjha 5y ago
Disclaimer: happy Sublime Text 3 and 4 customer.
I don’t really see the problem here? Like, ok, maybe you can be a bit upset that the app now asks you to upgrade, perhaps they should have used a less permanent reminder about that. But you can literally download every version of Sublime Text ever from the website, so if you don’t like the latest one with that you can just go back a version?
- blondin 5y agowhat a ridiculous take on the issue. if we want integrity and fairness in our field we need to apply it everywhere. giving passes isn't going to get us anywhere. the issue at stake is the use of dark patterns.
- harles 5y agoThe key issue is that the upgrade is essentially forced with no indication that it’s a major version upgrade or will invalidate the license. Going back to previous versions is a possibility but will require either permanently disabling updates or dealing with deceptive update pop ups. It’s also not obvious this is an option.
- jay_kyburz 5y agoThis is why I've made an effort to move away from Sublime. It's not so much the money, but this was just a real dark pattern and it made me question the integrity of the developers. Kate is really great these days. And then ZeroBrane for Lua and Rider for C#.
- guitarbill 5y agoI waited to upgrade to v4, which I've done now, and I'm still a happy ST user even though I had to pay. The upgrade dialog (in v3) nagged incessantly, and frequently. It produced a dialog on macOS eating keyboard input, and was really annoying. It wasn't obvious how to turn it off. And it could be more honest about requiring a license upgrade up front. So all of that wasn't the best thing ever.
- saagarjha 5y agoAh, I see. I guess I didn’t really experience that because I upgraded early. I had assumed it would just show the prompt once and then go away, but if it kept coming popping up yeah it isn’t great.
- jibes21 5y ago
- creativemonkeys 5y agoI'm not a SublimeText user (so I have no skin in this game), but from reading the discussion, it seems to me like the problem is as follows: 1. You bought a license to use SublimeText 3 in perpetuity 2. Later ST3 offers a routine update that doesn't communicate the fact that it is actually an upgrade to a product with a different licensing scheme. This comes as an unpleasant surprise to you. 2a. Additionally, applying a small update constitutes a small interruption to whatever you were doing (update, restart, continue editing). 3. Once started, ST4's very clear messaging is that you need a new license. 4. Because of #3, the minor interruption turned into a large interruption. Yes, people can go and downgrade, but _they shouldn't need to do that_. In my opinion, it's not OK for this to be the default behavior of an app, just like it's not OK for you to buy an economy seat on a flight, get reassigned automatically to business class and then be asked to pay a higher price for the same flight because you're now flying in business class. I think #2 was a mistake on ST team's part (which they acknowledge) and it makes them look unprofessional in this one instance. It is a frustrating experience, and it's OK and normal for users of SublimeText to feel frustrated. I want to make sure this is recognized, because saying "oh oops it was a bug" explains the root cause, but doesn't acknowledge the frustration it causes. I see this in software all the time. Software is for humans - we, as software developers, need to own the human consequences of these bugs as well, not just the technical side-effects.
- mrjin 5y agoI'm not SublimeText user neither. IMO the problem was really #2 and #3. It's perfectly fine to switch the license model between major versions, and it might even be fine between minor updates as long as the committed maintenance period elapsed. Doesn't matter which method was chosen, at least prompt the user before installing the update that a new license is required to continue installation. If the user opt to not continuing, then the upgrade should be cancelled, auto-update should be disabled permanently and no changes should be make to the users system. Sublime's behavior was deceptive and invasive, their users have all the reasons to grudge.
- joshspankit 5y agoWhile we’re here: I’m a free user, and because of it my “don’t check for updates” setting is ignored. Apparently you have to pay in order to disable the https request and the popup on each minor point release.