4 ms·
I find this unacceptable. Is there a list exposing such assholery so I can boycott accordingly?
by metadat 5y ago
I find this unacceptable.
Is there a list exposing such assholery so I can boycott accordingly?
- AdamJacobMuller 5y agoDepends who you think the asshole is in this situation? Airports? EU? Belgium? Lufthansa? Brussels Air?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jdavis703 5y agoThe buck stops with the airlines. Many airlines have been accused of colluding with “free market” ticket prices. Surely they could also enact a gentleman’s agreement not to “steal” each other’s slots until travel demand is back to 2019 levels?
- lstodd 5y agoThe issue is keeping crews from forgetting how to fly the aircraft. Or do you want another round of 737MAX because noone actually flown a plane in 6 months, since it was considered somehow better for enviroment?
- jdavis703 5y agoThe 737 Max crash wasn’t because of scarce flight hours. It was caused because the training procedures didn’t train pilots on how to recover from MCAS failure (and ultimately because MCAS itself was flawed). Has any transportation safety board cited flight hours as a cause in any of the crashes?
- lstodd 5y agoThe thing is, guys who actually knew what's a runaway stabilizer condition feels like managed to cope. It's the ones who didn't didn't. Somehow I think this is actually related to the hours flown. Not entirely, but should we take these chances? edit: Okay, that was exaggerated. Still, without regular practice the only thing there will be is more of perfectly avoidable crashes. We cannot trade people lives for some theoretical reduction in emissions.
- jdavis703 5y agoHow common of an event is runaway stabilizer on a commercial flight though? Of course it happens, but rarely. If we’re talking about practicing for rare events a few hours of simulator time that puts pilots through various crises would be more useful than 100 hours of uneventful flying.
- AdamJacobMuller 5y ago> It was caused because the training procedures didn’t train pilots on how to recover from MCAS failure I disagree only in that the focus should be at a higher level. Boeing was so focused on making sure that the 737MAX would be the same type rating as the 737, despite it having very different handling characteristics, that they developed things like MCAS which made it kinda-sorta like a normal 737, the only way that would succeed is if things like "MCAS failure" did not exist and therefore did not require training. It's not that they didn't properly train people on MCAS, it's the fact that MCAS shouldn't have existed in the first place.
- AdamJacobMuller 5y ago> The buck stops with the airlines Why though? I'm not a fan of government intervention in general, but, when the system colludes to accidentally create perverse incentives (flying empty planes) I don't see an issue with the government stepping in to make the situation less perverse (no flying empty planes) while maintaining reasonable equity (right of first refusal seems like a simple solution to that).
- jdavis703 5y agoI’m not saying the government shouldn’t regulate this (they should!). What I’m saying is the airlines are the ones ultimately dispatching these flights. Why do we all say “oh we can’t do anything about the tragedy of the commons until the government steps in?”
- lordalch 5y agoI'd say this is essentially an instance of the sequential monopolization problem and imperfectly aligned incentives due to a difference in the shape of each party's cost/demand curve. The classical example of sequential monopolization is a car manufacturer and a local car dealership. The manufacturer wants to sell a large number of cars at a fixed price, while the dealership would rather sell a smaller number of cars so that they can maximize their margin on each sale. Airports want high numbers passengers to maximize retail/parking/etc revenue (in which they have a monopoly), but don't directly care which flights are more profitable or how much the passengers pay for airfare as long as they fill the airport. Airlines are maximizing a different demand curve, in which most of their profit comes from a small number of profitable routes while most other flights are slightly unprofitable. Their biggest incentive is to prevent competition on those premium routes, which they can do by monopolizing flight slots. Sequential monopolization is a high-energy state for a market; absent other forces/regulations, it would be more profitable for the two companies to merge or otherwise form a partnership that looks more like a vertical monopoly. All that said, we only care about this because of the negative externalities created by the current equilibrium, both in the carbon cost of air travel and the massive taxpayer subsidies for airport construction that are wasted then that airport's takeoff and landing slots are inefficiently allocated. So, I'd say one possible solution would be to tax the airlines for the carbon used by all flights, perhaps at a penalty rate for flights above some amount of kg-per-passenger-mile.
- nickff 5y agoAre you planning to boycott the airlines or the airports? This waste was caused by airport policies; FTA: >"The news has prompted the Belgian federal government to write to the European Commission, urging it to rethink the rules on securing slots. Before the pandemic hit, the rule was that airlines must operate flights in at least 80% of their scheduled take-off and landing slots, or they risked losing them. This was revised down to 50% after coronavirus broke out, but this still remains much higher than the actual number of flights needed to meet passenger demand."
- mh- 5y agoBased on your quote, it seems like EC policies, not airport policies, no?
- AdamJacobMuller 5y ago> airlines or the airports If only they were the only choice! I would put the fault firmly in the hands of the bureaucrats or the politicians in the EU. This rule made sense pre-pandemic but it should have been adjusted for the current environment to something more like a right-of-first-refusal.
- skohan 5y agoIt's a bit of a hard problem isn't it? Flights and airport capacity have to be planned very far in advance and there are a limited number of slots - if you have airlines taking capacity and not using it, there's a huge opportunity cost for actual travelers who have to pay more, or can't get somewhere, because a necessary flight has been pushed out by an unnecessary one? It seems to me these kind of rules have a place, but should be expanded to take slots away from airlines which operate lots of mostly empty flights, not just cancellations. Of course I do think exceptions should be made for extraordinary circumstances like a pandemic.
- landemva 5y agoWalt Disney owns their amusement parks and seems to do okay balancing capital costs and visitor demand. Why should anyone think governments have a special ability to own and operate airports?
- themadturk 5y agoMy understanding is that this an international issue. It's something that made sense before the pandemic, since there is almost certainly competition for landing slots, but those slots should have been frozen when international flights so obviously dropped off in 2020. The FAA did drop the rule in the US, at least temporarily. Consider, though, that many of these flights are only empty of passengers. A great deal of air freight has always flown on passenger aircraft, much more than on dedicated air cargo flights, and planes without passengers are often flying with full cargo holds.
- refurb 5y agoYou gonna boycott the EU? It’s my understanding is this is a region wide mandate on the “use it or lose it” policy for slots.
- landemva 5y agoI have boycotted EU and Hawaii for the past couple years. It has not been worth the hassles to reliably obtain papers. Florida and Texas have been enjoyable. As AOC knows, no paperwork hassles there.
- skohan 5y agoI had to have a PCR test document to enter the US, but the vaccine was enough to return to the EU.