3 ms·
It's not "hysterics" - you're misunderstanding the problem. The problem isn't the presence of such functionality on your own computer. As you state, you're free
by mindslight 5y ago
It's not "hysterics" - you're misunderstanding the problem. The problem isn't the presence of such functionality on your own computer. As you state, you're free to ignore it [0]. Or even use remote attestation for your own purposes, which could be handy.
The problem we're reacting against is that when these chips exist widely enough, it becomes plausible for others to assert that everyone's computing device has one. At that point it's possible for third parties you want to interact with (eg your bank, government, entertainment provider, or even mundane web service) to start insisting that you use such chip's functionality to prove exactly what software you are running, for their "security" [1]. At which point it becomes impossible to run anything besides approved locked-down proprietary environments when interacting with such services.
As others have said, look at "SafetyNet" on Android. It's new enough that you can still pick banks that don't insist on dictating your computing environment, but with our moribund markets and monkey-see-monkey-do executives, the trend can only go in one direction.
[0] assuming no side channel between it and the network card(s).
[1] which they'll Orwellianly brand as "your security"
- philistine 5y agoHave you ever considered the possibility that SafetyNet, for example, exists because banks want to guarantee the transactions are indeed done by the user? It all goes back to the concept of the chain of trust. If a company can vouch for the code all the way from them to where it is running, that is an incredible improvement to security. Apple does it for its encryption and startup sequence, having delegated macOS to a read-only, signed volume on your disk that they can cryptographically guarantee has not been modified one bit. That, to me, is a great improvement in the security of our lives, and our banking.
- mindslight 5y agoYes of course, that is their obvious goal. Desiring ever more power to assure safety is one of the common motivations of authoritarianism in general. It's incompatible with a free society where power is distributed throughout many independent parties.
- philistine 5y agoFundamentally, I agree with you. However, the inability to access a banking system, or any system, without a cryptographic proof of your OS' source is such an overreach. When a company stops accepting faxes to conduct business, do we decry the slide to authoritarianism?
- mindslight 5y agoMy reference to authoritarianism isn't just a general frustration or condemnation, but rather because this technology specifically facilitates authoritarianism. It increases the ability of the more powerful party in a relationship to dictate the behavior of the less powerful party in a relationship. Sure, more powerful parties can always attempt to dictate such things, but the degree to which they succeed depends on how enforceable those terms are. Remote attestation directly enables such enforcement. Since central planning is unscalable, this inherently leads to mandates that are ignorant, arbitrary, and capricious. For example, perhaps a bank makes it against their terms to access your account through a virtual machine, due to a lack of understanding technology and a general worry - it's one more moving part and this user is doing something nonstandard that they don't understand, so to them risk goes way up. Yet I myself do all my banking access in a VM, for various security and practical reasons. But still I don't have to worry about any bank actually attempting to enforce such a clause, since unless they really start digging through my system stats with javascript and/or raw sockets, they won't even have any indicator of such. Whereas remote attestation would allow them to cut right through all of that and enforce such a thing (actually it would prevent it by default), thereby (increasingly) preventing me from operating my personal computing environment how I see fit.
- philistine 5y agoYou're decrying a technology not for its current benefits, but for its future potential unrealized risks. I doubt banking through a VM will ever be disallowed. There are too many benefits. Banning banking through a non-signed OS, sure.
- 5y ago