4 ms·
> in order for something to be read-only it's got to be a mask ROM or otherwise burnt-in (rather than merely undocumented flash), which implies being small. No
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> in order for something to be read-only it's got to be a mask ROM or otherwise burnt-in (rather than merely undocumented flash), which implies being small.
Not necessarily. Suppose you use ordinary flash but the write lines are physically not connected to it so there is no way to write to it from software.
In theory someone could desolder it and replace the contents, but if the attacker is desoldering your hardware, you've already lost.
> Also whenever you hear "security" you need to think "who's security?".
They try to sell people the "security processor" as a feature. It's important to make everyone aware of what it really is.
- mindslight 5y ago> The first copy ... cannot be modified after manufacture A second flash chip with a write disable line would also work, but that's not what you described. For one difference, it allows for evil maid attacks with an external flasher. > But they try to sell people the "security processor" as a feature. It's important to make everyone aware of what it really is. I agree, but it's not productive to just unilaterally define "security processor" the other way and talk past the problem. Either qualify it ("user representing security processor"), or otherwise make it clear that "security" doesn't always imply something good for the user (in fact in consumer marketing material it's more often harmful than good).