3 ms·
1. Rocket surgery is hard. 2. Going through several of the Apollo mission reports and accounts, it's clear that there were numerous additional instances in whi
by dredmorbius 5y ago
1. Rocket surgery is hard.
2. Going through several of the Apollo mission reports and accounts, it's clear that there were numerous additional instances in which missions could have been aborted or lost, above and beyond the Apollo 1 ground fire of the command module (three astronauts, Chafee, Grissom, and White, lost), and Apollo 13 (oxygen explosion in space, lunar landing scrubbed, no loss of life).
Apollo 11 saw a loss of landing computer and low fuel as the lunar module touched down. I believe it was Apollo 12 that was struck by lightning during ascent, and several other close calls.
For space flight to work, virtually everything has to go right. Not only is the domain tremendously complex, but tolerances are low.
On a related, unmanned mission note, the success (so far) of the James Webb launch and deployment is an impressive demonstration of technical execution and excellence.
- _hkzq 5y agoIt hasn't fully deployed yet. We'll have to wait and see.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI did say "so far". And my understanding is that the most complex junctures (launch, thermal shield deployment) have been completed. The thermal shield in particular is novel and no similar system has ever been deployed in space before. Success particularly on the first try is a milestone. (Makes one wonder if a "cheap" launch and trial deployment on a test or at least less-critical satellite might have been a testing alternative.) The remaining SPOF points should be very much reduced. Even if nonzero.