5 ms·
Huh? Anarcho-capitalism relies on cooperation, voluntarism, and humanism as much as any other anarchism. It just posits that respect for property, including gia
by gojomo 18y ago
Huh? Anarcho-capitalism relies on cooperation, voluntarism, and humanism as much as any other anarchism. It just posits that respect for property, including giant consensual property constructs like capital/corporations, is the best basis for creative cooperation.
- rw 18y agoDemand curves are not democracy.
- gojomo 18y agoBoth democracy and demand curves are means, not ends.
- stcredzero 18y agoHallelujah! Markets are great because they are a decentralized method for regulating resources that can adjust for changing conditions. One wants them in situations where there are too many factors and actors to be regulated by something as large and slow moving as a government. Markets aren't to be worshiped. They are a tool. Governments and laws are good for certain things too. I would like murder and violence to be illegal. I want human rights to be a given. Democracies aren't perfect, but they do embody a mechanism for ensuring the above. Unfortunately, they also allow their constituents to turn them into non-democracies. Democracies require constant maintenance.
- david 18y agoWho has committed more murders and violence in the past century? Random individuals/groups, or Governments? If you support nonviolence, why support an organization that threatens violence if you do not follow rules have no moral basis (ie, not "don't murder" and "don't steal") that you never agreed to follow?
- run4yourlives 18y agoDo you honestly believe that random individuals organized in some other fashion than government - say a corporation - are not just as able to murder and pillage on the same level as governments past? If you think that governments are some sort of special organization, and that the same problems would not occur with any other power, you sir are a fool.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoVoted up, but almost didn't with the reference to corporations being as evil as governments. Haven't seen that yet, mostly due to free market influences. (There is a good reason why your neighborhood store owner is not also a flagrant lawbreaker -- it's bad for business) But substitute "armed gangs", "the mob", "terrorist organizations", etc -- works great.
- run4yourlives 18y agoGive corporations power and an absence of government and it does happen. Look at the industrial revolution prior to workers' rights, or even look at telecom and communications monopolies today. That law that the store owner doesn't dare break is what holds him back!
- randallsquared 18y agoBut it didn't happen. No private organization ever produced something on the scale of the gulag or the Nazi concentration camps, even in places where government was very weak.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoCorporations are government-defined entities. You can't have them without governments. Not trying to argue, but it's a non-sequitur. The industrial revolution had corporations over-taxing the body politic. It was the natural result of taking rural agricultural ethics and putting them in a mechanistic world. It led to labor reforms. trust-busting, and labor unions. Sucked a lot, and lots of folks probably died early, but it was hardly the stuff of the holocaust. You have to remember that everybody was just figuring all this stuff out as it was happening. Once it became clear where we were headed (and that we didn't want to go there) then the government, which defines corporations, defined what they could and couldn't do in a different way. Badda bing, badda boom, your democratic republic at work.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- Prrometheus 18y agoAnd it is impossible to run an economy as prosperous as ours without "abstract institutions". By rejecting such institutions, left-wing anarchists are really rejecting modernism. Some of them understand this, but not all of them. Personally, I favor political systems which contribute to the further advancement of the human species. That's why I'm a right-wing anarchist. I have no nostalgia for tribalism.