4 ms·
When I was a kid there was a big earthquake where I lived and my life was disrupted for a few weeks. Many decades later I still have latent trauma from that inc
by paxys 5y ago
When I was a kid there was a big earthquake where I lived and my life was disrupted for a few weeks. Many decades later I still have latent trauma from that incident.
Children involved in situations like accidents, wars, disasters and abuse need years and sometimes lifelong therapy to deal with it. We are kidding ourselves if we think that the long list of behavioral changes we are starting to see in kids is simply attributed to keeping them at home, and when school reopens they will magically get back to normal. They have been exposed to non-stop disruption, illness, death and uncertainty for two years now.
Whether the covid pandemic goes away or not, a mental health one is upon us soon.
- pavel_lishin 5y ago> When I was a kid there was a big earthquake where I lived and my life was disrupted for a few weeks. Many decades later I still have latent trauma from that incident. From the earthquake, or from the disruption? It's an important distinction in the COVID case. Are kids being traumatized by having to attend school via Zoom, or are they being traumatized by living through a global pandemic?
- xboxnolifes 5y agoI don't think the distinction is important in any scenario. It's always the disruption. Put another way: if an earthquake happens, but nobody notices except the Richter scale, does it impact anyone? Of course it's not the pandemic term itself, it's the first-, second-, third-order effects of covid and the term pandemic. Zoom school, masks, vaccines, media coverage, political shifts, fights, worrying about family members getting sick (possibly dying), seeing your friends less, fewer/smaller gatherings, longer periods of isolation, etc.
- pavel_lishin 5y ago> worrying about family members getting sick (possibly dying) That was my point. Is what's hurting the kids having to stay home, and have Zoom meetings? Or is it the fact that they're literally living through a catastrophe? The former is nothing compared to the latter.
- josephcsible 5y agoMost people haven't really been affected by the disease itself, and instead were basically entirely affected by the measures put in place to try to slow its spread.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoI'd say that fear of infection, and your family members falling ill or dying, is separate from the measures put in place, and is a very real concern for folks of all ages.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoI'd think most kids don't actually worry about family members getting sick. They generally feel worry when their parents worry about family getting sick. So, they are being impacted by the social and emotional change in their environment, much less by disease itself. > literally living through a catastrophe Relax a bit.
- WalterBright 5y agoNo doubt some are long term traumatized by this. But a brief look at history shows that such things happening during childhood are normal, not exceptional. If most people need therapy to get back to normal, the human race would have died out. In my grandparents' generation, it was normal for a family to lose a third of their children before adulthood. The US has had devastating epidemics before, like the 1918 flu, and the polio epidemics.
- scottlamb 5y ago> If most people need therapy to get back to normal, the human race would have died out. I don't think "normal" and "human race died out" are the only options. Your grandparents' generation may not have ever had or gotten back to what we'd consider normal today. We always hope to make the world a little better for our kids than it was for generations before. Our kids will grow into adults, and they'll find their normal. But how different will that be from a world in which there was no pandemic? I don't know the answer.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe survivors of the pandemic will be, by and large, just fine. Like has happened with every other disaster.
- scottlamb 5y agoWhen your standards are the human race dying out or not, of course they'll be fine, and the survivors of all the other disasters have been too. But as a parent of young kids, my standards are clearly higher than that. As I said before, I want the world to be better for them than it was for the survivors of all those other disasters. On this forum, you're well-known and rightly get a lot of respect. You're a great technologist. If you were to just tell me something about programming language design, I'd generally assume you're right. If you gave rationale and sources, that's a bonus for my education. But on this thread...how do I put this nicely. As far as I know, you're not an expert in early childhood development, you're not a public school teacher, etc. I don't even know if you've been around children going through this. It doesn't comfort me much when you say they'll be fine. You're just some guy on the Internet. I know kids who've gone through this are struggling in many ways. My kids will probably be fine in the long run because I have the resources to help them. That still won't happen without considerable angst and effort on my part, that of their teachers, etc. Many other kids might be fine by your standards but not by mine. I'm not an expert in early childhood development either, but my understanding is there are certain critical years for language and social development that are golden opportunities. If those opportunities are missed, it's hard to fully replace them.
- zepto 5y ago> Children involved in situations like accidents, wars, disasters and abuse need years and sometimes lifelong therapy to deal with it. These situations have been very common throughout history, and are still prevalent in many developing nations, and yet somehow those countries generally have better mental health, at least by metrics of depression and anxiety.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hooande 5y agoPrevious generations endured wars and much more deadly pandemics. Do you have any idea how difficult it was and how long it took for black children to be able to go to school, at all? Man, it sucks that kids have to deal with this pandemic. But my grandparents had to deal with a whole lot worse than Zoom. The kids will be alright.