10 ms·
Archaeological dig reignites debate over the Old Testament’s historical accuracy
- dvh 5y ago- "Is it true that they give out free BMWs in Moscow?" - "Yes it is true. But it's not in Moscow but in St Petersburg. And it's not BMWs but Ladas. And they don't give it, they steal it"
- sysrpl 5y agoNo it's not. The Genesis account states that the earth was created, then the oceans, then trees and plants, and after all that the sun the moon and the stars were created. The correct historical order is stars existed, then the sun was formed, then the earth and moon, then oceans, and finally trees and plants.
- commandlinefan 5y agoInteresting that your mind immediately goes there. I read the title and wondered about the historical accuracy of, say, Abraham offering his wife to pharaoh or Solomon killing his brother to ascend to the throne. With a handful of exceptions, after the part with the Ark, the old testament is at least believable.
- katzgrau 5y agoI was like, pretty sure all those people didn't live 900 years. I like a lot of the stories and subjective meaning, but you kind of have to look past the odd factoids.
- mch82 5y agoAs a thought experiment, could it be a units translation issue? A person who lived 175 seasons (each 3 months long) would be 44 years old. A person who lived 900 moons would be 74. It’s happened to spacecraft, http://www.cnn.com/TECH/space/9909/30/mars.metric.02/ http://www.cnn.com/TECH/space/9909/30/mars.metric.02/
- jcranmer 5y agoPeople have suggested that it's miscounting months as years, but that now means you get 10 year-olds (and sometimes even younger!) popping out babies, which doesn't make that much sense either.
- soneil 5y agoI find it interesting that the Sumerian King List exhibits the same behaviour. The earliest kings rule for tens of thousands of years (each), the second wave rule for hundreds of years, and the third wave rule for tens of years ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumerian_King_List https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sumerian_King_List ). So I'm left with three thoughts that don't necessarily agree with each other. One, is that it seems fairly obvious that there's some transition from oral histories to written histories; and the closer the event was to the written record, the more realistic it gets (which we also see in the OT). Two, is that there's a lot of crossover between Sumerian kings and Gods, so it doesn't seem inappropriate for the oral tradition to imbue kings with god-like properties. (As an aside - I can easily imagine that in tens of thousands of years from now, with fragments of records remaining, someone could argue with a straight face that the early space-agers actually believed Queen Elizabeth was immortal and semi-lizard. This is obviously comical, but does illustrate the risks of an oral tradition.) And three - the possibility that there's intermingling between these two traditions? Or that there's some cultural factors here where we're seeing the effects without the causes (ie we're not seeing why it was popular to assign these characteristics to ancestors, only that they did so). But to come back a little more on-topic - Sumer is also where we get the sexagesimal (base-60) numbering that we still see in time & angles. So when comparing units, there could be some mistranslation between different number bases at some point.
- jazzyjackson 5y ago> space-agers actually believed Queen Elizabeth was immortal and semi-lizard Oh my god I'm picturing bojack horsemen as the last surviving digital media; not so different from ancient hieroglyphs of animal heads and human bodies...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- soneil 5y agoI find "the part with the Ark" fascinating. The number of different traditions that have a deluge myth has to make you wonder if there isn't something behind it. Obviously if you take it very literally, every species on earth in the back of a homemade boat, the entire planet being wiped out, etc - it doesn't stand up very well. But I'd be willing to entertain the possibility that the story is the fossilised remains of an oral tradition that predates the written record - perhaps the loss of lands after the last ice age, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flood_myth
- xaedes 5y agoHere is something from Zoroastrianism akin to the Ark, connecting it with winter and "foul frost": FARGARD II. Yima (gamshêd). And Ahura Mazda spake unto Yima, saying: 'O fair Yima, son of Vîvanghat! Upon the material world the fatal winters are going to fall, that shall bring the fierce, foul frost; upon the material world the fatal winters are going to fall, that shall make snow-flakes fall thick, even an aredvî deep on the highest tops of mountains. And all the three sorts of beasts shall perish, those that live in the wilderness, and those that live on the tops of the mountains, and those that live in the bosom of the dale, under the shelter of stables. Before that winter, those fields would bear plenty of grass for cattle: now with floods that stream, with snows that melt, it will seem a happy land in the world, the land wherein footprints even of sheep may still be seen. Therefore make thee a Vara, long as a riding-ground on every side of the square , and thither bring the seeds of sheep and oxen, of men, of dogs, of birds, and of red blazing fires. Therefore make thee a Vara, long as a riding-ground on every side of the square, to be an abode for men; a Vara, long. as a riding-ground on every side of the square, to be a fold for flocks. There thou shalt make waters flow in a bed a hâthra long; there thou shalt settle birds, by the ever-green banks that bear never-failing food. There thou shalt establish dwelling places, consisting of a house with a balcony, a courtyard, and a gallery. Thither thou shalt bring the seeds of men and women, of the greatest, best, and finest kinds on this earth; thither thou shalt bring the seeds of every kind of cattle, of the greatest, best, and finest kinds on this earth. Thither thou shalt bring the seeds of every kind of tree, of the greatest, best, and finest kinds on this earth; thither thou shalt bring the seeds of every kind of fruit, the fullest of food and sweetest of odour. All those seeds shalt thou bring, two of ever, kind, to be kept inexhaustible there, so long as those men shall stay in the Vara. There shall be no humpbacked, none bulged forward there; no impotent, no lunatic; no poverty, no lying; no meanness, no jealousy; no decayed tooth, no leprous to be confined, nor any of the brands wherewith Angra Mainyu stamps the bodies of mortals. In the largest part of the place thou shalt make nine streets, six in the middle part, three in the smallest. To the streets of the largest part thou shalt bring a thousand seeds of men and women; to the streets of the middle part, six hundred; to the streets of the smallest part, three hundred. That Vara thou shalt seal up with the golden ring, and thou shalt make a door, and a window self-shining within.' https://www.sacred-texts.com/zor/sbe04/sbe0408.htm https://www.sacred-texts.com/zor/sbe04/sbe0408.htm
- SeanLuke 5y agoActually there are TWO incompatible accounts of creation in Genesis, one in Genesis 1 and one in Genesis 2. Genesis 1: the world initially all water. God has to dry it to create land. Genesis 2: the world initially all land. God has to add water. Genesis 1 creation order: water, land, plants, animals, humans (male and female at the same time, most reasonable reading is many humans all at once). Genesis 2 creation order: land, water, Adam alone, plants, animals, Eve alone.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dane-pgp 5y agoThe two accounts aren't necessarily incompatible, and they can be interpreted as offering two parallel perspectives of Creation: the first with a cosmological focus, and the second with a sociological one. A synthesis of the two accounts would give an order something like this: Fluid (the proto-Earth which didn't have a distinct atmosphere), solid Earth (with liquid water forming oceans, and a gaseous atmosphere), plants, animals, humans, Adam, the garden of Eden (in an area that had been barren), (animals brought to Adam for naming), Eve.
- SeanLuke 5y agoMeh, apologetics. Either the water was first or the land was. Either man was explicitly created before the plants, or he was explicitly created 3 days after them. On and on. There are tons of irreconcilable differences among the creation accounts.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads into religious flamewar. It's the last thing we want here, and it's particularly easy to avoid. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sysrpl 5y agoThe original title of this submission until it was changed was "Is the Old Testament historically accurate". My response was to that title, no it isn't historically accurate.
- dang 5y agoI know, but you broke several of the HN guidelines with that response, including these: "Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html The article is obviously talking about historical accuracy in the context of archaeology and really in the context of a specific archeological dig. It's not about whether God created the earth in 7 days or put a bunch of animals on a boat.
- that1dude 5y agoExcept fact is not provocative at all. They were objective with their answer and did not respond in a way that was derogatory nor mean spirited. They didn't even mention their opinion on religion, just responded "No, here would be the sequence of things". That's not even critical. You trying to weaponize the guidelines is an abuse of the community and against the spirit and purpose of the rules.
- dang 5y agoThat's a strained interpretation both of the GP comment and of the HN guidelines. I'm pretty sure the bulk of the community here doesn't want to argue about whether the creation story of Genesis is "factual" or not. There's zero intellectual interest in that; it is, in fact, an absurd thing to argue about, unless you feel charged up about religion somehow. > fact is not provocative at all. There are infinitely many facts. They don't select themselves—humans do that—and often they do it in a highly provocative way. That's why "I'm just stating facts" is one of the classic troll tropes. For example, if one middle schooler points out the acne on another kid's face, that's both factual and provocative. I've used that analogy before. Recently I ran across an old comment by pg where he made a similar point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6539403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6539403. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20infinitely%20many%20facts&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jjtheblunt 5y agoPossibly related, but not mentioned: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyksos#Potential_biblical_connections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyksos#Potential_biblical_conn...
- sabertoothed 5y agoNo. A better title could have avoided this simple answer.
- dang 5y ago"Please don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- commandlinefan 5y agoIf nothing else, the old testament is a fascinatingly well-preserved look at how people viewed life thousands of years ago. Although a lot of things have changed, the nature of human conflict and the desire for power haven't.
- lalaland1125 5y agoI think the most interesting part of the Old Testament is how the ancient Israelites justified their war against Canaan. One of the main charges against Canaan is that they accused Canaan of sacrificing children. It's the exact same "think of the children" justification used endlessly today.
- zozbot234 5y agoIt was a real thing, we know the same stuff from Roman sources about Carthage which shared much of their culture with Canaan.
- garbagetime 5y agoI don't think that was in dispute
- lalaland1125 5y agoI guess it's just hard to take that justification of trying to stop child sacrifice seriously when the same text describes the ancient Israelites proceeding to kill all the boys and enslave all the girls from captured Canaanite cities. It seems like the primary goal of the war was simply conquest, not freeing Canaanite children. With the child sacrifice simply being used to justify that expansionary war.
- tsol 5y agoIt's hard to take Americans seriously when they say they're for women's and children's rights, when they proceed to kill and rape innocent women and children in the middle east. See how easy that is to do?
- gigel82 5y ago
- rbanffy 5y agoA tamer version of the title would have prevented 50% of the comments at this time. We can try "new evidence of an advanced society in the time of the biblical Solomon" would probably be a better fit.
- ducharmdev 5y agoYeah, the final line seems to be far from any kind of "gotcha": > What Ben-Yosef has produced isn’t an argument for or against the historical accuracy of the Bible but a critique of his own profession. Archaeology, he argues, has overstated its authority. Entire kingdoms could exist under our noses, and archaeologists would never find a trace. Timna is an anomaly that throws into relief the limits of what we can know. The treasure of the ancient mines, it turns out, is humility.
- Spooky23 5y agoA lot of the status quo understanding of the past is filtered through British Imperial Era historians and archaeologists who in turn interpreted through the eyes of the world order they lived in. Every once in awhile there’s a headline to the effect of “Breaking: Scientists discover that Bronze Age/medieval/not European people were total idiots in <year>“
- User23 5y agoIt raises questions that anatomically modern homo sapiens existed for at least 200,000 years, but supposedly only developed civilization in the past five thousand years or so. Perhaps human civilization is considerably older than the mainstream view, but 5,000 years is about how long it takes for all traces to disappear? It does appear the great pyramid will probably be extant for longer than 5,000 years, but such artifacts appear to be rare. My very limited understanding is that traditional Hindu teaching is that human civilization is orders of magnitude older than 5,000 years. If anyone who knows more about that wants to reply I’d be interested.
- UperSpaceGuru 5y agoDavid Graber’s new book leans onto this: the dawn of everything
- Ekaros 5y agoIs any historical text from similar time period accurate?
- joshdance 5y agoCould be. I think the most interesting part of the article is that they have identified a limit of archeology. They discovered wealthy and powerful groups that don't exist according to archeology because they didn't leave behind buildings. The royal purple dye was very interesting as well.
- ianbutler 5y agoI think it's interesting that it feels like we have such high expectations of archaeology to provide mostly accurate pictures of history when if we were wiped out tomorrow our historical record would exist for what 10000 years before everything is completely degraded? Most of that information loss would happen in like the first 100 years after we were gone just based on how quickly most of our digital storage mediums degrade. If we can't build a long and comprehensive enduring legacy of our civilization why should we expect older civilizations to have been better at it while theoretically having worse means to do so and expect that legacy to be wholistic when archaeologists explore it?
- maartenh 5y agoOne thing I really like about Doctor Who, is the absurd mis-remebered fake histories they make up for our current era. Hilarious! Puts into perspective how we think about the cultures that came before us.
- ArtWomb 5y agoI mean check out that 3000 year old smelting furnace. Not only does it work as a piece of aesthetically intriguing sculpture, it probably still works as a blast furnace! I think about this a lot actually. When ancients built, they had to built for survival, so the focus, care and attention was exponentially multiplied. The result is of course things that were implicitly designed to last for generations. It must be an amazing feeling to be an archeologist at the moment of new discovery. You suddenly enjoy a serendipitous connection with a human being who has been dead for ages. But is suddenly memorable again, as if reborn. I think that human connection is the seed of "psychohistory". What message or wisdom can we wish to convey to our Future Selves?
- mikepurvis 5y agoNot an archeologist, but isn't most of what we find pretty sharply split between everyday stuff that was frozen in time or left behind in an unplanned catastrope (Anasazi, Pompeii, etc), and then the formal, intentional records left in tombs and so on? I know both pieces are important, but the intentional record of some ruler tells you more about their ego than what everyday life was like. I expect that even if we were all snuffed out tomorrow, there would be loads of our record remaining 1000+ years from now— both the intentional efforts like seed vaults, time capsules, stacks of hard copy documents sealed in safes, but also the enormous presence of all kinds of plastic, which even divorced from context would still give myriad insight into what daily life was like at the start of the 21st century.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomohawk 5y agoThe tent theory makes a lot of sense. Prior to Solomon's temple, the temple was a tent, and is recorded as being a tent for hundreds of years. A lot of scholars used to insist that the Bible was obviously not historical because it talked about this thing called the Assyrian empire that had conquered the fertile crescent, and everyone knew that empire never existed. And then in the mid 19th century archeologists unearthed extensive evidence of the Assyrian empire. Interestingly, records from that empire concur on some of the same events in the Bible. For example, Sennacherib is mentioned as the leader of Assyria who conquered most of Judah (the southern kingdom of Isreal - he had already conquered the northern one). See, for example, Isaiah 37. From an unearthed clay tablet: "But as for Hezekiah, the Jew, who did not bow to my yoke, forty-six of his strong walled towns, and innumerable smaller villages in their neighbourhood, I besieged and conquered by stamping down earth ramps and then by bring up battering rams, by the assault of foot soldiers, by breaches, by tunnelling and military engineering operations. I made to come out from them 200,150 people, young and old, male and female, innumerable horses, mules, donkeys, camels, large and small cattle, and counted them as spoils of war. He himself I shut up like a caged bird within Jerusalem his royal city. As for Hezekiah, the awful splendour of my lordship overwhelmed him." This coincides with the account in the Bible. Note that Hezekiah is a descendant of Solomon - less than 200 years separate them.
- wl 5y ago> A lot of scholars used to insist that the Bible was obviously not historical because it talked about this thing called the Assyrian empire that had conquered the fertile crescent, and everyone knew that empire never existed. > And then in the mid 19th century archeologists unearthed extensive evidence of the Assyrian empire. You're conflating the Assyrians and the Hittites. The Assyrians were well known from sources other than the Hebrew Bible before the decipherment of Akkadian cuneiform and modern archeology. Even then, Archibald Sayce's 1876 identification of the Biblical Hittites with the Hittite Empire of Anatolia remains problematic today. You're also drawing up a bit of a strawman of pre-19th century scholars—the problem of the Biblical Hittites never seems to have been more than a minor curiosity for those arguing over the value of the Hebrew Bible as a historical work. Also, if you're going invoke Sennacherib's Annals to compare with the Biblical accounts, actually compare them. Briefly, the Hebrew Bible has Hezekiah paying heavy tribute (though not as heavy as in the Annals) to Sennacherib so he won't attack, Sennacherib lays siege anyway, and then divine forces destroy Sennacherib's army.
- furrowedbrow 5y agoLoved this article, thanks for sharing!
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI am reminded of a piece I read about a dig in either Central or South America. It was probably a thousand years old and archaeologists were baffled by something commonly found in the burial sites. A local fisherman was able to readily identify it as a spacer for making fishing nets with consistently sized openings. So much of what gets left behind only makes sense if you have knowledge of human behavior. It isn't necessarily readily inferable from the physical remains themselves.
- readthenotes1 5y agoI got chills when I read about the protagonist being too fearful of the wrath of the mob to publish his theory until after he got tenure. Reminded me of the quip that science advances one gravestone at a time.