3 ms·
Honestly, as much as I like the tech that Rossmann shows, the trappings he wraps his videos in makes it very hard to digest. I feel his arguments always miss t
by csydas 5y ago
Honestly, as much as I like the tech that Rossmann shows, the trappings he wraps his videos in makes it very hard to digest.
I feel his arguments always miss the simple fact that he has no idea how much trouble not-including such restrictions actually cause, and he over-estimates his audiences' skill/underestimates his own skill, muchless over/under-estimating his willingness to accept responsibility compared to most consumers.
The software I work on has a simple database we use to manage the configuration, and it's a CONSTANT battle with "knows enough to be dangerous" DBAs/IT persons to argue that we're not going to fix the DB after they went through and did their own edits to try to fix an issue and the end result was they only made the situation worse.
The argument of "well, publish more info on the DB" falls flat for me as we constantly published information on which program versions and what specific issues the edits applied to, and our clients simply didn't care; our clients aren't just average users, they're allegedly IT professionals like anyone you might imagine reading HackerNews. We had cases that lasted for months over who was responsible for the issue when the client clearly admitted they just hacked the DB with a chainsaw.
Rossman has some great knowledge and I absolutely do agree with his position on Apple making it too hard to repair their stuff. (Based on the most recent MacBook Pro, seems Apple also agreed...) But I think Rossman fails to appreciate the scale that many companies are dealing with and the sheer volume of customers who absolutely screwed up such rudimentary repairs and then try to blame the company for [the customer's] own ineptness, and how a lack of legal language to specifically protect the company from such behavior opens up very long and difficult legal and PR battles.
Rossman has good knowledge, but I don't feel he's giving a good faith interpretation as to where such policies and ideas come from, and he'd be far more effective in his communication if he simply left his videos at the point where he demonstrated the simplicity of the repair without the tirade. I don't know what Rossman's liability policy looks like for the repairs he does, but I don't get the impression he takes on a lot of liability compared to what I've dealt with across many different products.
- csydas 5y agoAddendum (adding as a separate post), but I want to respond to this specifically: > But to forbid me, presumably an adult, is a different thing. I prefer to own my own property. I appreciate you accept responsibility for yourself, but please understand that it's a real legal argument to say "well, nothing specifically said I __couldn't__ do $thing, so I assumed it was safe to do so. I never imagined $thing could be so disastrous! Why didn't you include a warning?" Such matters always boil down to a fairly protracted argument, sometimes of the legal persuasion depending on the country of residence for the customer. It really is a case of a few bad eggs ruining the bunch. No one will stop you from hacking the car (e.g., the Mercedes police aren't gonna roll-up and arrest you for opening the hood), but for sure if they find your attempted repairs actually exacerbated an issue, the clause helps back that they tried to warn you "don't mess with this stuff it's not supported".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dogleash 5y ago>I don't feel he's giving a good faith interpretation as to where such policies and ideas come from good faith - noun - honesty or sincerity of intention Isn't this a company that illegally conspires against even their own employees?
- FL410 5y agoThere is a real difference between a) refusing to deliver a database "manual" with your product and b) actively and continually obfuscating or engineering your product to block your customer's attempt to fix things at their own risk. IMO.
- Volker_W 5y ago> the trappings he wraps his videos in What does this sentence mean? (Grammatically, English is my 2nd language).
- roomey 5y agoAll the extra bits included in the video that are opinions or segments unrelated to the core message of the video