2 ms·
Using IQ as a concept to enshrine intelligence is a terrible mistake IMHO because it encourages this toxic RPG-enshrined idea that intelligence is a number that
by Quarrelsome 5y ago
Using IQ as a concept to enshrine intelligence is a terrible mistake IMHO because it encourages this toxic RPG-enshrined idea that intelligence is a number that goes up. That makes it only slightly better than it being just a bool. We don't even begin to know how to measure intelligence or what is in or out of scope when we use the term "intelligence". So to use such a study as a short hand to suggest a country is getting "stupider" or "smarter" just feels like shamanic rune throwing.
We could suggest that IQ is a measure of intelligence but I would argue that IQ only matters if you're applying to university which also gives it this correlative value of "wealthy" and "parents that care" if you're cherry picking economic outcomes which makes it hard to pick apart as a vacuumed characteristic. It also is a very narrow measure given that the breadth of human endeavour requires a lot more types of intelligence than just shit-hot pattern matching.
- throwaway5590 5y ago
- throwawaygh 5y agoOP's beliefs about how IQ is used in intelligence research -- and in particular this paper -- are almost entire correct. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29798887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29798887
- Quarrelsome 5y agoI would suggest reading less Stormfront mate. They lap this shit up over there and hence I have a very cool point of view on people that believe deeply in IQ and also lack the eloquence to tell me _why_ they think I'm wrong.