2 ms·
Agreed. My concern is precisely with this conflation of Theranos's negligent misconduct with the exercise of the fundamental rights which allow us to fix our c
by kragen 5y ago
Agreed. My concern is precisely with this conflation of Theranos's negligent misconduct with the exercise of the fundamental rights which allow us to fix our cars (if you fix your car without a shop manual, you're doing reverse engineering --- and both Chilton and Haynes do reverse engineering to write their shop manuals), fix our laptops (see Louis Rossmann), uncover Microsoft's dirty tricks to break competitors' software (reverse-engineering was crucial to the antitrust trial), preserve our information (both PDF and Word formats were reverse engineered before they were opened), use IBM-compatible PCs (the clone industry was able to launch because Phoenix reverse engineered the BIOS and wrote a cleanroom clone), and generally do anything with a manufactured device that the manufacturer didn't intend.
For this reason there are carve-outs in copyright law where something is illegal except when done for the purpose of reverse engineering; for example, in the US, you have Sega v. Accolade.