3 ms·
This looks like a big, time-consuming project that would rely on a private Google API that can change any time. I think it's not worth to invest your effort int
by fsflover 5y ago
This looks like a big, time-consuming project that would rely on a private Google API that can change any time. I think it's not worth to invest your effort into that. I wish more people would help to improve FLOSS, peer-to-peer search engine YaCy instead, https://yacy.net https://yacy.net.
- TrueDuality 5y agoThis improves other search engines as well, not just the Google universe. I'm sure even an opensource, peer-to-peer search engine will have similar issues of content farm content and gamed pages if it becomes large enough to compare with search engines like DuckDuckGo. On the other hand it is absolutely ridiculous to conflate the difficulty of occasionally adding a domain to a local filter, and assisting to build a random unproven search engine. People volunteer their development effort for projects they personally find interesting or challenging. If you want more developers advocate for the project don't try to scold people for wanting to spend a small amount of their time refining a solution that works for them.
- upbeat_general 5y agoI’m not sure why you think that a domain blocklist would be harder than custom search engine development. Plus there’s no private Google API here, just an extension that removes search results from the page. I suppose you could say the extension APIs are from Google (Chromium) but they’re certainly not private and are commonly used.
- fsflover 5y agoDoesn't this extension depend on how exactly the ads are presented on the page? Can't this be changed by Google easily? > I’m not sure why you think that a domain blocklist would be harder than custom search engine development. I didn't say this. The custom search is already created. Helping it's development is much easier now. AFAIK it's main problem is the lack of hosted servers.
- upbeat_general 5y agoI'm not sure about the specifics on how uBlacklist works but these[0] uBlock origin filters seem to be very basic and invariant to small changes. Google could certainly could make them harder to remove but given that they don't put up much of a fuss (to my knowledge) for their normal ads (YouTube not included), I don't see why this would be otherwise. Fair enough about a custom search engine though, I misinterpreted your comment. [0]: https://github.com/stroobants-dev/ublock-origin-shitty-copies-filter https://github.com/stroobants-dev/ublock-origin-shitty-copie...