4 ms·
On the other side, one might make the argument that someone with millions of dollars to spare on early-stage investments should also be able to do their own due
by mschuster91 5y ago
On the other side, one might make the argument that someone with millions of dollars to spare on early-stage investments should also be able to do their own due diligence on investments - otherwise, why would the status "accredited investor" be required? And, implicitly, that people like Holmes and Madoff who decide to exploit greed and unprofessionalism serve a vital purpose in a free market by acting as predators removing weak elements from the market.
Experts have warned from the beginning that Theranos made unrealistic to impossible announcements. Anyone investing at that scale without consulting experts IMO does not deserve protection from the law.
If Theranos is one thing, it is a real life example of why group dynamics and investing don't mix, and why the best thing to come out of r/wallstreetbets is the saying "do your own DD".
- metabagel 5y agoFor the most part, it wasn’t really possible to perform due diligence in this case, because Theranos refused to submit to an audit, and otherwise lied and actively prevented investors from getting the true story. For that reason, some potential investors walked away.
- datavirtue 5y agoShe straight up said she was backed by partnerships with big pharma and that the device was working. I would have invested in a heart beat given the claimm. Lying at that level is insane. She need removed from the presence of law abiding citizens as long as possible.
- moron4hire 5y agoI've been involved in investment due diligence investigations. You don't just take people's word for that sort of stuff. You literally pry through everything and confirm it for sure.
- bumby 5y agoI think that argument gets lost when the company actively lies. In Theranos’ case, they forged letters by Pfizer claiming the system was validated. If a company is forging, say accounting books, it’s hard to claim due diligence would have prevented being swindled.
- mschuster91 5y ago> In Theranos’ case, they forged letters by Pfizer claiming the system was validated. Wirecard did the same with accounting statements from the Philippines, and EY accepted them without verifying that the statements are correct at the bank offices, they didn't even cross check if the billions of dollars could even be on the books of the Philippine banking system, and now EY is in hot waters. If I were an investor and were presented with claims of validation of a technology that is hotly contested, the very first thing I'd do is call up or otherwise contact the issuer and verify the authenticity of that claim. It's like ten minutes to find out the contact information of Pfizer's Investor Relations team and compose a letter - investors who are unwilling to commit at least this little bit of verification deserve to be relieved of their money and office.
- bumby 5y agoEY = Earnst & Young? You bring up good points (although I think I disagree with your conclusion that people ‘deserve’ to be defrauded). There seems to be active collusion at times between oversight and the companies being audited. This isn’t the first time EY has been accused of this and we see it with credit ratings agencies too. I think I come to a different conclusion because we all outsource our quality assurance on a daily basis. Did you review the airworthiness certificate of the last plane you flew on? If not, do you “deserve” to crash because you outsourced to the FAA without verifying it yourself? I’d say the blame should fall to the third party auditors who failed the system, not necessarily to those who trusted them.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Did you review the airworthiness certificate of the last plane you flew on? If not, do you “deserve” to crash because you outsourced to the FAA without verifying it yourself? Am I a normal airline passenger/pilot or did I sign up as a test pilot for experimental / new / freshly repaired aircraft? The latter get higher pay simply because that risk is part of their job, and to my knowledge test pilots have the option to refuse jobs they deem to be too dangerous. Same is for investors, with the difference that human lives can irrevocably be lost whereas money is only a virtual thing.