3 ms·
So I am an author who made significant money on his copyrighted works, and I think that copyright terms should be reformed (and mostly shortened) too. My main
by inglor_cz 5y ago
So I am an author who made significant money on his copyrighted works, and I think that copyright terms should be reformed (and mostly shortened) too.
My main beef with the long term copyright system is that it does precisely the opposite what it is supposed to do: it suppresses creativity by making it legally risky to derive works even from abandonware. Everyone discusses Cinderella, but IMHO the worst problem with long copyright is the huge, huge pile of semi-orphaned or utterly orphaned works that no one is legally allowed to touch, even though they do not make any money for their creators and heirs. This is a pure dead weight loss.
IDK how big this pile of untouchable works is, but I would guess that over 99 per cent of copyrighted works do not make even a dollar a year after some 20-30 years since their publication.
So my reform, that would actually consider the interests of both small creators and big corporations, would be return to the double-tiered system:
- every work would be in automatic, free copyright for 20 years,
- after that, the owner of the copyright would have to register the work in a publicly accesible catalog for a very mild fee (something like 3 dollars yearly). That fee would prevent spamming of the database by frivolous requests, but would winnow out works that are no longer, or never have been, commercially interesting for their creators. It would also make easier lives of other people who would be interested in licensing said work, because they would know whom to contact. This second phase could be much longer, perhaps for 80 years.
I would be happy, as an author, to subject my own works to similar rules (actually I release my texts much sooner.) And this scheme would solve the abandonware problem, returning civilization to its original way of building art - which is derivation from the earlier works.
- IanCal 5y agoI've wondered about a system where after a short initial period you pay a fee based on a value you assign to the copyright. The twist being that this value is then used for the sale of the copyright. Disney say that Mickey mouse is worth $1M to pay lower fees? OK but anyone is able to buy the copyright for that amount. By keeping something in copyright you're stopping everyone else from using it as they want, and asking the government to enforce this for you. In return, you should pay for that privilege. Having one system/cost for both my small run book and the basis for multi-billion dollar companies feels odd though. You could have the fee scale based on age, or not. Curious to hear where this poorly spec'd system would fail, so am putting it on HN to be dismantled :)