3 ms·
This really misses the point. Any well-informed individual can cut their sugar intake if they are careful enough. But that has no effect on the massive public
by ncmncm 5y ago
This really misses the point. Any well-informed individual can cut their sugar intake if they are careful enough.
But that has no effect on the massive public health crisis unfolding that (e.g.) absolutely dwarfs COVID-19. Liver disease caused directly by sugar intake is indirectly responsible for many often-fatal conditions, including high blood pressure, diabetes, circulatory disease, even metastatis of cancer. The only thing that can have any effect on that is massive policy changes, and a re-architecting of the public food supply.
This is not impossible: we have mostly eliminated hydrogenated fat from the US diet (although I recently found you can still buy Crisco at the grocery store!) So, artery blockage and heart disease from that will be on its way down. It took Fred Kummerow his entire career to get hydrogenated fat out of the American food system, from the '50s well into this millennium, but not substantially until 2017, even though it was known to be poison. (Europe banned it earlier.)
Try finding even a loaf of bread in the bread aisle of your supermarket that is less than 10% sugar. (You might find one or two. Good luck.) Even the multi-grain "healthy" ones are loaded. Check your sauces. Ketchup, mustard, barbeque sauce, mayonnaise, salad dressing, peanut butter, all usually have lots of sugar. So, even if you think you have cut it out, you probably haven't.
Kids have massive promotions directed at them to make them demand unlimited amounts of sugar. It works, they get it. Kids in the US are getting cirrhosis, like alcoholics.
This is not about self-discipline, it is about public policy. People will eat what is promoted to them, that they find on the shelves at the store, on the menu at the drive-through, in the snacks stock at the office. They will keep eating it while it makes them sick, and even while it kills them. (My mother-in-law died in October. She packed on sugar right to the end.)
- phonypc 5y ago>Try finding even a loaf of bread in the bread aisle of your supermarket that is less than 10% sugar. What is meant by this? Even on the high end, standard Wonderbread isn't 10% sugar by weight. 10% sugar by calorie content, or a serving accounts for more than 10% RDA? A banana would be far worse by those metrics.
- ncmncm 5y agoBananas, like almost all fruits (excepting grapes) have enough fiber to render the sugar mostly harmless. The label will say something like "Serving size: 31g ... Sugar: 3g". Bread is at the low end.
- bigyellow 5y ago
- Py-o7 5y agoThere are some good points in here about NAFLD. It's worth pointing out that (i) high sucrose (and/or fructose) intake makes it hard for people to self regulate appetite (i.e. not overeat). And (ii) the above stated ill effects of high sugar consumption are basically stopped in the presence of a caloric deficit -- e.g. IIRC there are controlled chimp studies on this and inadvertent human 'experiments' like with food shortages in Cuba in the 90s. But I don't think (ii) is particularly relevant for rich countries whereas (i) is. >This is not about self-discipline, it is about public policy. it can be instructive to compare school lunches in the US vs other rich countries. Not everyone serves highly processed junk food for lunch.