5 ms·
Without wanting to or being able to contradict the article, some of it sounds like the creationists. Because we cannot fully explain evolution, we do not know a
by croes 5y ago
Without wanting to or being able to contradict the article, some of it sounds like the creationists.
Because we cannot fully explain evolution, we do not know all the ancestors and the result is so complex, there must be a creator.
I hear exactly the same argumentation from creationists when it comes to the development of the human eye, for example.
- chana_masala 5y agoYou might find the work of David Gelernter (computer scientist) interesting. He's not a creationist, but he has abandoned the theory of evolution. > Suppose, then, that every bacterium that has ever lived contributes one mutation before its demise to the history of life. This is a generous assumption; most bacteria pass on their genetic information unchanged, unmutated. Mutations are the exception. In any case, there have evidently been, in the whole history of life, around 10^40 bacteria—yielding around 10^40 mutations under Axe’s assumptions. That is a very large number of chances at any game. But given that the odds each time are 1 to 10^77 against, it is not large enough. The odds against blind Darwinian chance having turned up even one mutation with the potential to push evolution forward are 10^40x(1/10^77)—10^40 tries, where your odds of success each time are 1 in 10^77—which equals 1 in 10^37. In practical terms, those odds are still zero. Zero odds of producing a single promising mutation in the whole history of life. https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/giving-up-darwin/ https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/giving-up-darwin/
- jagger27 5y agoI really regret spending time reading this drivel.
- yyx 5y agoIt took 4 billion years to get to this point. Plenty of time.
- chana_masala 5y agoIf you read the full review, it's not at all.
- dboreham 5y agoBut if you add space travel...
- yellow_postit 5y agoThis is Intelligent Design dressed up in hand wavy math that builds on misrepresentation of cited studies and the fossil record. Read with a strong dose of skepticism.
- chana_masala 5y agoCan you expand on the misrepresentation of studies and fossil record?
- chana_masala 5y agoThe book is about Intelligent Design, but the reviewer (Gelernter) as far as I understand is only claiming that the theory of evolution doesn't hold. He is neither a creationist or proponent of ID
- ufo 5y agoBy this logic, artificial selection is also impossible and therefore pugs, tomatoes, and fancy pigeons cannot exist.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Gigachad 5y agoIt would be more credible if you knew for a fact that there are people manufacturing and studying eyes. Even if you don't know exactly how the eye you are looking at got there.
- rleigh 5y agoEvolution occurs gradually, one base-pair at a time through replication error (or various other effects). Occasionally you get big changes through duplication, transposition or deletion of whole parts of a sequence. But the latter hasn't occurred here--we're looking only at the former. When we study evolution over time, we can look at the accumulation of silent and non-silent point mutations. And we can also pick up any larger insertions and deletions. From this data we can create a graph of the changes over time based upon relatedness (the phylogenetic tree). This is the data shown in the article. When looking at a large sampling of data across an entire population, we would expect to see a gradual accumulation of point mutations over time. And very rarely, some larger insertion or deletion event. None of this is new. We had all the tools to do this for over two decades. I was using Perl for bioinformatics 15 years back. So given the assumption that we would see a gradual accumulation of point mutations over time, if we see any big changes appear out of the blue, that's a flag to investigate more closely at what happened. That's not "creationism" of any sort. Given that the point mutations give a very clear fingerprint, we can immediately find the most closely-related genome, which is why it was found to match a sample collected in early 2020. That completely breaks our expectations of it missing a whole 12 months of natural accumulation of point mutations. We might not sample perfectly--we might occasionally see two or even three point changes because we failed to sample those intermediate states. But to have a jump spanning dozens of changes--that's just not matching our existing expectations, particularly when we tracked nearly every Delta change. Now that might be real. But the probability of that being natural is very, very low. Almost nonexistent. But the chances that this was stuck in a freezer and pulled out, skipping over those 12 months of mutation-gathering while frozen in a tube, are unfortunately a much more likely possibility.