3 ms·
I'm afraid that 100 years are not achievable in a guaranteed way because of the tin whiskers phenomenon [1]. Maybe covering the solder surfaces with thick, har
by nine_k 5y ago
I'm afraid that 100 years are not achievable in a guaranteed way because of the tin whiskers phenomenon [1].
Maybe covering the solder surfaces with thick, hard resin could help. (So goes repairability.)
[1]: https://www.microcontrollertips.com/when-tin-whiskers-spontaneously-erupt-faq/ https://www.microcontrollertips.com/when-tin-whiskers-sponta...
- kurthr 5y agoWhile I agree with the sentiment... especially for ultra low cost solutions, the availability of Pb-Free HASL, Organic coatings, and NiAu plating make Sn whiskers much less of an issue than they were 10+ years ago. Through-hole components again might be lowest cost tin coating, but that's also easily fixed. Incremental 10% cost increases can dramatically improve long term and high temp reliability. Most SMT parts are pretty safe, because the suppliers are afraid of contaminating their supply chain. Even for commodity parts (Cell phones and Laptops) PCBs and components are built to prevent problems with Sn. Certainly, in Automotive it's a big deal!
- bullen 5y agoSo then just use a brush and rub the PCB every 5 years? I mean they can only grow through air right? My 35 years old breadbins show no sign of these, maybe they have more lead in them... time will tell! How ironic if the old breadbins outlive modern hardware!