2 ms·
Because lawyers and publicists cost $$$ and the payoff is indirect and broadly dispersed across population and time, rather than arriving in the form of a check
by anigbrowl 5y ago
Because lawyers and publicists cost $$$ and the payoff is indirect and broadly dispersed across population and time, rather than arriving in the form of a check. It would require at the least 10s of millions in lobbying expenses, and raising that amount of money in the name of an abstraction is likely a non-starter.
You could run a piracy website that only offered works more than X years old, where X is some popular proposal for a reasonable term, and then fight a test case. To my mind the best legal argument against the current regime is that the Constitution's specification of 'limited time' copyright has been extended to be longer than the median human lifetime, thus making it effectively perpetual for most humans in the US; this also hinders the formation of a constituency for shorter periods because fewer and fewer people have had the experience of seeing a work they admired at the time of publication subsequently enter the public domain.
But realistically, any test case is likely to fail because higher courts would probably just say 'the term might be effectively infinite for people but it's short in the lifetime of a nation and corporations are arguably immortal so no media giveaway for you peons.'
- shmerl 5y agoI think piracy still sounds like the most reasonable counter measure to such inability to roll back this insane term length, caused by legal system dysfunction. If everyone will just ignore that term, it won't matter anymore.