3 ms·
No. The other moats are lock-in to advertising networks, website metrics, and effective control over Web standards through the Chrome browser. An alternative
by dredmorbius 5y ago
No.
The other moats are lock-in to advertising networks, website metrics, and effective control over Web standards through the Chrome browser.
An alternative search platform might provide better search. It would be fighting Google on at least three other fronts. It might have some success, but it would be challenging. (As history largely demonstrates.)
Even a rival tech monopolist, Microsoft, barely holds even with its own search offering (I use that indirectly via DDG), and scrapped its own web-browser development
- gomox 5y agoI mean, Google is big and it has that advantage like any big enterprise, but the search engine market is very permeable compared to what people traditionally refer to as a moat (say, trying to compete with YouTube as a video hosting platform or with Salesforce as a CRM). If you have a good search engine, people will flock to it, and search ads will be valuable. That's it. That's how Google became Google. The fact that Microsoft couldn't do it honestly doesn't mean much. Microsoft also couldn't do a phone OS, a portable music player, and many other things. They have a complex web of conflicting interests that $SEARCH_ENGINE_STARTUP does not.
- dredmorbius 5y agoJust for the record, I'm in at least mild agreement that search is looking increasingly vulnerable. Google are falling down here. It's just that "search" is really a web of interrelated services, capabilities, and revenue streams, and they tend to reinforce each other strongly. I'd like to see the monopoly disrupted.[1] But I don't think it's just a matter of "build a better mousetrap^Wsearch engine." Attack one corner, and Google will snipe at you from the others. And with the AdWords cash cow, they've got an immense revenue stream. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Well, mostly. Google's acquired so goddamned much personal data that the premise is frankly kind of terrifying as well --- a weakened Google with neither the revenues nor talent to defend that pile.... And I'd really like to see the toppling occur without simply raising a new monopoly in its place.