5 ms·
> I thought about emergency breaking automatic vs. manual and I actually feel safer knowing that the car can potentially break faster. For me, the knowledge th
by bob1029 5y ago
> I thought about emergency breaking automatic vs. manual and I actually feel safer knowing that the car can potentially break faster.
For me, the knowledge that some other engineer designed a system that is a complete black box (from my perspective), which can arbitrarily stop my car with incredible braking force is terrifying.
What happens if the emergency braking system decides to have a bug while you are exiting the freeway at 75mph?
- l33tman 5y agoI do share your concern... but somehow I (perhaps naively) feel there is a big difference between regulatory mandates like emergency braking, that all manufacturers in the EU has known and planned for since more than 15 years, and stuff like Teslas FSD-beta which is a disaster to happen running on our streets.
- martin8412 5y agoMy concern is if the engineers were qualified and allowed to follow proper protocol for designing safety critical systems.
- bob1029 5y agoAlso consider the budgets these engineers have to work with now. If cars had an average unit cost measured in 7-9 figures (i.e. like a Boeing 777), I would have substantially more trust in everything involved.
- seized 5y agoYeah, Boeing is a solid example of that whole large budget == safe mentality.... Maybe in 2022 exclusively.
- therealcamino 5y agoThere's not a simple relationship between cost of the end product and the budget for developing safety-critical systems. There are only ~1600 777s ever built. The development costs for automotive systems are amortized over millions of units. I have no idea what the budgets actually are, and it's fine if you don't trust certain kinds of automation in cars. In fact my 2020 Toyota with lane-keeping assistance tried to drive me off the freeway at 80mph three times last week. (I probably should have stopped trying it after the second time, but I was kind of morbidly fascinated at that point. As it steered me firmly towards the grassy median, it also started beeping urgently to tell me that it wasn't a good idea.)
- userbinator 5y agoAll that cost, and they still screwed up with the 737MAX...
- jacquesm 5y agoI've written about this before on HN, I had a late model C class Mercedes that decided to emergency brake on the surface of a small bridge sending the car into a spin, the same thing happened in a turn when there was a large sign present. In both cases the error seems to have been related to the radar picking up a return and interpreting that as an imminent frontal collision when there was absolutely no reason for that. I had the vehicle checked out, they said it was performing to spec so I sold it. No more Mercedes for me.