3 ms·
This is a clickbait article that doesn't deserve a place on HN. So let's forget the "bro" aspect. Some methods of soil rejuvenation are very compatible with mod
by noduerme 5y ago
This is a clickbait article that doesn't deserve a place on HN. So let's forget the "bro" aspect. Some methods of soil rejuvenation are very compatible with modern farming, and some farming in the US still depends too heavily on chemical fertilizer.
In the mid-1800s, the "Great American Desert" was rebranded the "Great Plains" in a marketing campaign designed to get poor Irish people to go out and populate/farm it. That whole mess ended up with the topsoil getting blown off after a single generation of farming. Meanwhile, we now understand "soil" as a very complex substance, more organic than mineral. If they had understood that then, they would have had a better yield and the Army Corps of Engineers wouldn't have had to come in and rebuild Oklahoma and half of Arkansas from scratch[0].
For all the wonderful development of the 20th Century, lots of mistakes were made and lots of land was destroyed to achieve a brief burst of productivity, and lots could have been made more sustainable, and still could be.
[0] https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA637016 https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/citations/ADA637016
- nerdponx 5y agoAre there any good books on this topic? Plenty has been written about "The West" in general, but specifically the agricultural history of America seems like it'd be both interesting and enlightening.
- littlestymaar 5y agoAnd this isn't limited to the US, the soviet did the exact sale things in Khazakstan[1] with the same consequences… [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Lands_campaign https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Lands_campaign
- noduerme 5y agoAlso in Argentina. It's a settler/imperialist pattern. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquista_del_Desierto https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conquista_del_Desierto (Not in Israel, though; when I say "settler/imperialist" I suspect some people might draw that conclusion. Israelis don't waste the land or practice these kinds of short-sighted farming techniques.)
- kiliantics 5y agoI'm not so sure about that. Israel seems to only be capable of its agricultural miracles thanks to over-extraction from freshwater aquifers, including those belonging to Palestine
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agodon't they have a lot of polytunnels?
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Not in Israel, though; when I say "settler/imperialist" I suspect some people might draw that conclusion. Israelis don't waste the land or practice these kinds of short-sighted farming techniques It's not really surprising, since their territory is very small (even though they are expending it on a regular basis, it's still very much bounded, because expanding outside of Palestine would be almost impossible). I think it has a lot to do with the idea of having a land so vast that you can't really imagine exhausting it (of course it only happens during colonization because the “big land” is otherwise divided between many competing factions, each controlling a tiny part of it)
- noduerme 5y agoMm. Yes, also a misunderstanding of fertility. The Israelis for instance were of a mindset to go into an extremely arid place and plant grasses and harvest water until they could hold down the dunes in some places, grow crops in other places. Whereas there was a big misunderstanding in the 1800s, in the plains of Argentina and the Great Plains of America, that the thin soil which supported grasses would be able to support wheat or corn. The constant replanting without rest or irrigation was more like a religious belief than an understanding of the land. Maybe yeah, too much land can lead people to casually screw it up. Or on the other hand, knowing your land is so small and limited makes you have to act more carefully...