6 ms·
I was born there. I spent the first eleven years of my life there. I'm white, and got sick of all the "You don't look like you came from Africa!" jokes, at abou
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I was born there. I spent the first eleven years of my life there. I'm white, and got sick of all the "You don't look like you came from Africa!" jokes, at about age twelve.
And no, I've never been in South Africa. I hear that it's beautiful.
The people I knew were awesome, but there's a lot of serious cultural trauma, in many of the varied peoples of Africa. Some of it was caused/exacerbated by colonialism, and some of it is far older than The Great White Hunter.
It's important to note that there are vast cultural and societal differences between various African nations and tribes.
Come to think of it...the same can be said about Americans. Put a New York pizza joint owner from Brooklyn, next to a Louisiana shrimper, and tell me they're the same.
Africa has enormous natural resources. Unfortunately, access to these resources has been one of the things that colonialism messed up. They can't own the stuff that comes up out of the ground.
Unstable governments have been an endemic problem (See "colonialism," above). Poverty is an issue, but it isn't necessarily worse than in many other places on earth (but it is pretty damn bad, if you are used to the US version of "poverty"). Poverty does tend to breed the kinds of people that turn into nightmare dictators, though.
A lot of the issues that people think "only happen in Africa" also happen in other parts of the world. What happened in the Balkans was every bit as bad as some of the awful tribal conflicts that we've seen from Africa.
I desperately want Africa to come into its own. That will take a heck of a lot of things that I'm not qualified to prescribe.
[EDIT]: I removed one line that probably set some teeth on edge. Upon reflection, it's not necessary to the narrative.
- kspacewalk2 5y ago>Unstable governments have been an endemic problem (See "colonialism," above). That implies other causes (which you yourself mentioned above) are minor by comparison. Surely this was true in the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s. But now, 50-60 years later, that explanation alone just doesn't cut it. A lot of places were colonized outside of Africa too, often much more brutally than many parts of Africa (whose colonial legacy is as heterogenous as other things you mention), and are on average doing better (hence the ugly 'poor man Africa' caricature this piece lampoons so well). And yet the onset, length or brutality of colonization doesn't seem to coincide well with stability or quality of governance. Heck, Ethiopia almost got away with not being colonized at all. Like yourself, I don't know what to prescribe. I do know that it should be Africans themselves doing the prescribing.
- bingohbangoh 5y agoI think his broader point was that unstable governments exist today and also existed before with colonialism as one example of many.
- rayiner 5y agoBlooming unstable governments on colonialism requires more evidence than is offered. Most people in the Indian subcontinent, where I’m from, perceive British colonialism as positive with respect to government, institutions, and rule of law. Former colonies like Hong Kong and Singapore have developed into thriving civilizations.
- tptacek 5y agoAre you asking for evidence that colonialism was damaging to African governance? Or just for evidence that British colonialism was?
- rayiner 5y agoI’m asking for evidence that colonialism caused African governments to be unstable. If Africa hasn’t been colonized, what would the continent be full of countries with stable governments today?
- tptacek 5y agoI don't know, but I can't help but notice that your examples of colonies considered long-term beneficial are all British, and, obviously, Africa was not colonized exclusively by the British. It wasn't the British who, in the 20th century, chopped off the hands and castrated rubber farmers who couldn't make their quotas. For that matter, India gained independence in 1947; Singapore in 1959. Africa was colonized into the 1970s.
- rayiner 5y ago> It wasn't the British who, in the 20th century, chopped off the hands and castrated rubber farmers who couldn't make their quotas. So is that the reason governments in African countries are unstable? Castrated rubber farmers?
- scabarott 5y agoAs an African, born and bred who "looks like I came from Africa", I really really hate it when a European person writes about Africa. They tend to end up writing things like the energy and enthusiasm of the African people is inspiring as hell with no clue whatsoever how immensely condescending and patronizing that comes across. Let me transliterate that so you have a little bit of an idea: the energy and enthusiasm of European people is inspiring as hell. I know the poster is probably well meaning yet the post comes off ironically in exactly what the essay is describing - as if the poster didn't read that before saying their piece about "Africa"
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoHey, thanks for being nasty. I know exactly what the essay was describing. Most of the kids I played with, are probably dead. They almost certainly died horribly. Maybe some of them became child soldiers, and killed and raped. I could have gone on about how I had to treat PTSD, from my experiences over there, but I didn't think that would be helpful. But I really appreciate your "putting me in my place." I guess I needed it. I've often found, in my experience, that initiating a relationship on a confrontational basis, is not a particularly good idea. Have a great day.
- prmph 5y ago> Most of the kids I played with, are probably dead. They almost certainly died horribly. Maybe some of them became child soldiers, and killed and raped. I’m also African and currently live in Ghana, and I fail to see how this is representative of the experiences of African children in general. I do think the comment you’re replying to went a bit overboard, but I fail to see how your comment is proper rebuttal to it, which is disappointing because I was interested in how you would address his substantive point
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI lived in Uganda. It was quite representative of the situation there, at the time (1973). And...that's exactly why I didn't mention it in the first post. I am talking about my own life, here, and the experiences that I had, and the points of view that I developed, as a result of the experiences in my life. I'm not particularly thrilled about being told that my experiences and my life is somehow "invalid." I wasn't speaking for anyone else. I have had family that were heavily involved in a lot of fairly fundamental African development work, anti-corruption (and anti-communist) stuff, and had to leave two countries, because of horrendous wars (Nigeria, in 1966, and Uganda, in 1973). These were my experiences, and my words. Feel free to share your own thoughts and experiences.
- lisper 5y agoWhat part of Africa are you from? My wife and I are heading to Africa in a week. This will be our fifth visit. We've been to 18 African countries. This time we are going (back) to South Africa, Kenya, and Tanzania. Absolutely love it there, but I try to remain mindful of the fact that it is often easier to love a place as a tourist than as a resident.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI lived in Nigeria, Morocco, and Uganda. Uganda is probably one of the most beautiful places on earth. Its political situation is still quite unstable, but the climate, landscape, and wildlife are second to none.
- Guessnotgauss 5y agoHeres a reminder of Gel-Mann amnesia, Im seeing alot of speculative comments on colonialism in a broad sense in Africa. Which is fine, but the nuance is that there were many different colonizers, they left all at different times, and their influence is very much still being used to maintain resource rights and extraction. Without a small bit of history and perspective you might assume the dictators are a direct result of their respective people's poor choices. The cold war wasnt easy on Africa. People are still desperate for changes that aren't serving the status quo. Did anyone do their degree in comparitive politics of Africa? Political Science is hard because everyone has such a strong bias and a lot to say about it. Dont forget your grains of salt.