3 ms·
You hit the nail on the head -- repeatedly. Shit. I just bought my gf a Roku as a stocking stuffer. We were setting it up and it made her put in her email and p
by noduerme 5y ago
You hit the nail on the head -- repeatedly.
Shit. I just bought my gf a Roku as a stocking stuffer. We were setting it up and it made her put in her email and phone number to verify. I was appalled; I was like don't put in your email! I'll return it! But she wanted be able to watch YouTube on her TV since Apple removed it without warning from her AppleTV device. My own Roku from a couple years ago works great with no idea who I am, let alone my phone number.
Someone said users tolerate it. I think this has a lot to do with corporations getting out ahead of the law, doing diligence on their own just in case one government or another comes knocking. Yeah, in the case of a streaming device they probably gain a bit of extra intel to sell if they have a phone number to tie to your viewing habits. But it's not just that. Google just asked me on one of my fake accounts to tell them "Charlie's" birthday, just in case so they don't serve me any illegal material. This is to pre-comply with whatever data the government of any country they serve might want.
Now, the problem with Amazon's hostility toward customers of its marketplace is of a whole other order. That's truly a situation where it's cheaper for them to sell rotten garbage to everyone and take returns than it is to make a transparent marketplace, and that's down to the laws of physics. They just make more money being a shipping company than they do a retailer, and the arbitrage between Chinese factory sellers and American consumers is ridiculous. You could design countless better systems, but none of them will ship lead-coated childrens toys as quickly or for as much profit.
This here's the last of the free internet that isn't dumbed down for consumers. This and the retro BBS subculture, and gopher and IRC and other things of that ilk. We're much reduced.
Personally in my own code / administration and training for the company I work for, I really try to make sure that the user experience comes first and there is no daylight between what the customer expected and what they get. This, however, is a minority view.
- toastal 5y agoRoku is now publicly traded so its beholden to getting quarterly value for shareholder. Investors have deemed all of this data collecting valuable. Capitalism killing innovation by making it another homogeneous device that doesn't respect you doesn't surprise me.
- noduerme 5y agoMe neither in the long run, but it definitely surprised me on Christmas Day how much data they wanted to collect. One bit at a time I've been offended and shocked by it since I came back to this country in 2015 but I gotta say, watching how totally docile and copacetic my girlfriend was about this boot-up experience was more interesting than any of what they were trying to collect. It was totally weird to her that I was telling her not to put in any of this info and that I would return it for her. She was done entering her data before I could mount a full argument why she shouldn't. I know, I'm just a hideous boyfriend. That's not the point though. I was really offended and I tried several ways to get around the boot process without verifying by email. This only succeeded in delaying our HBO show by 20 minutes. She was just like, let me do this. Ok no problem, she said, I verified it. Now how are gonna expect companies to act civilized when almost everyone's already conditioned to hand over their life every time they're asked?
- robertlagrant 5y ago> Capitalism killing innovation by making it another homogeneous device that doesn't respect you doesn't surprise me. What is this weird fascination with capitalism on HN? If a socialist government thought collecting data was a good idea and directed its resources that way, would that okay? My read is (rightly or wrongly) they want to have cloud services, and cloud services require identification.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> What is this weird fascination with capitalism on HN? It's the one doing the data collecting in our lives.
- noduerme 5y agoParent's point is that you'd be a lot less likely complain about even worse data collection if you lived in China, and it was done in the name of the "people" - but you wouldn't be quieter because you really believed it was for the people. You'd be quieter because you were scared to say things about the System. You're lucky to live in a System that pays you to have a public opinion about it.
- ninkendo 5y ago> We were setting it up and it made her put in her email and phone number to verify. I was appalled; I was like don't put in your email! I'll return it! I’m glad to know I’m not the only one still trying to fight this fight. It’s really starting to be a problem with games. Buying games during the holiday Steam sales used to be a big part of my holiday break, something that was my way of winding down after a long year. But I’ve made it a personal policy to refund any game that requires an account to play (I only play single player games, there’s no reason for games to have my email.) Nowadays this means basically all AAA games are off limits to me. Gaming in general is becoming less and less of my life as a result. I had originally hoped that some PM somewhere would see refunds coming with “requires signup” as the reason, and would maybe second guess requiring signin for future games, but it just keeps getting more and more ubiquitous. At this point I’m just saying farewell to gaming. It was once something that gave me a lot of pleasure, but I can’t participate in this industry any more. There’s other things I can do with my time.
- bryguy32403 5y agoIt's even worse with games. If you buy a game on steam, steam has an account api that is completely usable for online play, but the game companies want more data so they force you to make an account with them. I have a stadia account and I've taken to doing the same thing. If i go to play a game and the first thing it wants me to do is create an account, I'm not playing that game, and I'm telling support about it.
- noduerme 5y agoWhy not just set up a throwaway email for all of it? =\
- ninkendo 5y agoFor me, it's the principal of the thing. It's not that it's such a terrible thing for a company to know my email address (especially when apple makes it trivial to create throwaway ones for your iCloud account, their "hide my email" feature has improved so that now you can just make bespoke randomly generated email addresses that look exactly like an unassuming iCloud account, but forward to yours.) The reason I do this is because I am so fundamentally against the concept of a gaming company harvesting personal information about its users, that I feel like a shitty person for being complicit in it. I'd rather miss out on the occasional good game than be "part of the problem".
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> But she wanted be able to watch YouTube on her TV since Apple removed it without warning from her AppleTV device. Apple did not remove the Youtube app. Youtube made changes that caused their app to no longer work on older Apple TVs. The Apple TV that are no longer compatible with YouTube’s app (and CBS and MLB) were released before 2015. It is reasonable that an Apple TV released in 2012 to not have the technical specifications to be compatible with other providers after Mar 2021 due to rapid changes in technology and software. https://9to5mac.com/2021/03/03/older-apple-tv-will-require-airplay-for-youtube-video-playback-starting-next-month/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/03/03/older-apple-tv-will-require-a... https://9to5mac.com/2021/03/02/apple-tv-3-losing-signal/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/03/02/apple-tv-3-losing-signal/
- falcolas 5y ago> It is reasonable that an Apple TV released in 2012 Respectfully, I disagree. To the point where I want to yell at the screen. If the appliance still works, don’t stop supporting it. 9 years is not that long of a time. I don’t care that it means more work for the development team. They had software working for it, and at its core YouTube is just displaying streaming video. If it can work on a $15 Roku stick, it can run on an Apple TV of any flavor. Please stop perpetuating all this BS that we should be replacing our perfectly functional hardware every 5 years and keep software working.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoApple does still support it. Apple’s own shows work on it. > They had software working for it, and at its core YouTube is just displaying streaming video. Who is they? It takes 2 to tango. What is Apple supposed to do if YouTube/CBS/MLB decide to stop sending MP4 video and the device they started designing 10+ years ago was only designed to play that (or not play what ended up being the winning format)?
- falcolas 5y agoThis rant wasn't aimed at Apple - sorry if that was unclear. It's aimed at YouTube devs (and developers in general) - the ones who stopped their support.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> I was like don't put in your email! I'll return it! I was in Las Vegas with family a couple of years ago and there's a zipline over Fremont street that my kids wanted to do. They wouldn't let us do the fucking zipline until I gave them my email address.
- noduerme 5y agoHeh. I grew up in Vegas. I mean, it's full of surprises. I always watched those people going down the zipline on Fremont and thought they were pretty silly, but I never realized they had to give their email address. Meanwhile around the corner behind the Heart Attack Grill, there's a man who will hand you an axe and let you throw it at targets for a few bucks, no questions axed. I miss the old America sometimes.