3 ms·
To summarize this paper in a less technical way than the abstract does: This paper finds very strong evidence that omicron jumped to infecting mice in May 2020
by londons_explore 5y ago
To summarize this paper in a less technical way than the abstract does:
This paper finds very strong evidence that omicron jumped to infecting mice in May 2020, then jumped back to humans again in Nov 2021.
* Mutations in the spike protein, which are likely to depend on which animal is best infected, were a far closer match in mice than any of 20 other species tested (P<1.6x10^-11 )
* The types of genetic changes (ie. transitions from one base to another) were not those expected to be found in human cells, but were those expected to be found in mouse cells (P<0.008)
* Omicron binds far better to mouse cells receptors than any other animal or human tested (P<1x10^-5 )
* The genetic changes seen happened at a rate far 3.3x faster than expected in humans.
(my summarization here has traded scientific accuracy for simplicity)
Any of those fist 3 bullet points I would consider pretty decisive evidence. To have found all three is amazing.
- jonathanstrange 5y agoWow, those P values are very low. Is this normal in this type of research? Are they calculated directly based on combinatorial arguments?
- londons_explore 5y agoNo. P values this low are very rare. I haven't checked any of the analysis with my own data, but the approach seems pretty legitimate. Each is calculated in a different way, using mostly-non-overlapping evidence, so it's almost legitimate to multiply them together to get P<1.3x10^-18... Not that there's any need - each alone is very convincing. The whole lot really should have been written as three separate papers, with better written abstracts, and a metapaper, written by different authors, combining the evidence and comparing to the evidence for other hypothesis.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MontyCarloHall 5y ago> Are they calculated directly based on combinatorial arguments? Yes. Most of the extremely low p-values come from binomial tests with a very low binomial probability p_bin relative to the fraction of positive outcomes. For example, > We identified 45 point mutations that were introduced in Branch O (hereafter referred to as “pre-outbreak mutations.”) We observed that the pre-outbreak mutations were over-represented in ORF S (P = 1.2 × 10−13, binomial test with the expected probability equal to the length of ORF S relative to the SARS-CoV-2 genome). So p_bin = len(ORF S)/len(genome). The spike protein sequence (ORF S) is roughly 1300 bases and the entire SARS-CoV-2 genome is roughly 30 kilobases long, yielding p_bin ≈ 0.04. If there are 45 total pre-outbreak mutations, and assuming they ought to be uniformly distributed across the genome (big assumption, BTW!), then seeing 17 of them occur in the spike protein sequence would yield a binomial p-value (one-sided test) on the order of 1e-13. The other low p-values either also come from binomial tests with similarly low binomial probabilities relative to positive outcomes, or from Fisher exact tests with gross imbalances between categories (and high counts to back those up).
- londons_explore 5y agoNote that there is some dubious stuff in the paper... Figure 3 B for example is deceptive... Drawing ellipses onto principal component analysis charts is never a rigorous way to know if something fits in a set... You are only visualising the first two components - and for all you know, the point you're querying might be miles away in the third axis that you aren't looking at. High dimensional data is high dimensional for a reason - conclusions you make by throwing away most of the data aren't robust! Despite that, I still believe the overall conclusion of this paper is backed up by very strong evidence.