4 ms·
Large File Transfers Over The Internet: Unsolved.
- jesstaa 15y agoNAT is pretty much solely to blame for this issue and the main reason by ipv6 can't get here soon enough.
- thaumaturgy 15y agoHeh. We've run into this very problem for one of our clients, who occasionally needs to share hefty files with remote contractors. Dropbox and other centralized services was a no-go. It needed to be idiot-proof. We're just about done coding up a pretty nice little system that allows users to log in and upload a file through a web interface along with a destination email address. File gets permanently stored to their local server along with some other details, and a copy gets temporarily sync'd up to an external server with better bandwidth. After the sync is complete, an email is sent to the destination, and the recipient receives a link to click on which will immediately begin the download, with no intermediate nonsense. Files can be downloaded only once, and only for a specific period of time (currently hardcoded to 24 hours; configurable later). Information is recorded when the file is downloaded, and sync'd back to their internal server. Admins can choose to receive email notifications when files are shared, and can later look at the originals. It's pretty OK. I've been thinking about adding it as a what-the-hell feature to some of our other stuff. Maybe I should.
- jcr 15y ago“Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of backup tapes hurling down the highway.” - Andrew S. Tanenbaum
- 0x12 15y agoI made an easy to use service for this purpose, up to 100 MB upload. Within weeks it was a hotbed of .rar files with very questionable content so I shut it down. I don't have time enough to babysit each and every upload. Worked like a charm, killed by the jerks.
- jcr 15y agoWhich jerks? The jerks stealing creations from creators? i.e. you consider intellectual property laws to be fair and violation of these laws to be theft from the creators. -or- The jerks stealing creations from the public? i.e. you consider the imaginary property laws to be corrupt and the existence of theses laws to be theft from the public. Though often an unpopular opinion, these days, both sides are jerks. The idea of a "short-term and temporary COMPROMISE for the advancement of the useful arts and securing the rights of the public" was lost a very long time ago.
- 0x12 15y agoThe service was not intended for any copyrighted content, just as an easy way to pass files from one person to another that are too large for an email. So, the 'jerks' would be those uploading any kind of copyrighted content, but especially those that figured this was an easy way to create a child porn file exchange. Apparently I'm too naive to think ahead.
- jcr 15y ago> Apparently I'm too naive to think ahead. Call it a lesson learnt, and don't feel to bad about it. After all, you are in excellent company; forgetting to prevent abuse by default can be found in inventions like email, ftp, usenet, www, javascript and countless other "successes" of technology.
- raghava 15y agoIn bandwidth starved places (India, Africa), such a method itself seems more suitable. Some even found carrier pigeons to be useful for the task. (http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/09/09/us-safrica-pigeon-idUSTRE5885PM20090909 http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/09/09/us-safrica-pigeon-... )
- pasbesoin 15y agoThis was posted 6 hours earlier, with the wrapping XKCD page as opposed to the bare PNG graphic linked here. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2976780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2976780