3 ms·
I find the idea that excessive sugar intake messes with all sorts of our systems entirely plausible - we definitely aren't designed to consume the quantities of
by inglor_cz 5y ago
I find the idea that excessive sugar intake messes with all sorts of our systems entirely plausible - we definitely aren't designed to consume the quantities of sugar that we on average do consume; and especially not non-stop for years and decades.
Teasing out all the causal chains will be hard work, though. Metabolism is really complicated. Sugar increases levels of insulin; fructose kicks liver into overdrive; how does that excessive metabolic activity work out in remote parts of the body such as the brain?
- colechristensen 5y agoWell we’re not designed. Plenty of our primate relatives eat mostly high sugar fruit based diets. More important than what we eat, we didn’t evolve in an environment where we had infinite easily available calories.
- ncmncm 5y agoEverywhere sugar appears in nature (with the exception of beehives), it comes with fiber that slows its absorption. Uniquely (with the exception of bees) we separate it from the fiber and deliver the sugar without. The whole food-processing industry is largely devoted to removing and discarding the fiber we need to remain healthy.
- erosenbe0 5y agoJust bees? What about maple syrup?
- cdot2 5y agoI believe theres a lot of processing before you get the maple syrup that you find in stores so its not really found in nature
- wfhpw 5y agoMaking maple syrup from sap is an illuminating experience. You have to reduce something like 40x the volume of sap to create the desired quantity of syrup.
- Brave-Steak 5y ago
- ipython 5y agoBut most people don’t consume maple syrup, they consume high fructose corn syrup with artificial flavoring. You have to go out of your way and pay a lot more $$$ to get “real” maple syrup. For example, the ingredient list from Aunt Jemima syrup: CORN SYRUP, HIGH FRUCTOSE CORN SYRUP, WATER, CELLULOSE GUM, CARAMEL COLOR, SALT, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVOR, SODIUM BENZOATE AND SORBIC ACID PRESERVATIVES , SODIUM HEXAMETAPHOSPHATE
- katbyte 5y agomaybe its because I'm Canadian but no one I know would consume anything but real maple syrup, I never encountered anything else until I went to the states.
- chrisweekly 5y agoThe discussion was about maple syrup, not that HFCS junk.
- ncmncm 5y agoMaple syrup does not, in any case, appear in nature. It is another product of industry.
- briHass 5y agoMaple syrup is highly, highly concentrated sap. The sap itself is mostly 99%+ water, with just a slight sweetness to it. To make syrup, you have to boil away almost all of that water, going from gallons of sap to only a small amount of syrup. That boiling process and amount of sap required is partly why it's so expensive. It's like aged whisky: you lose so much of what you started with.
- senectus1 5y agotrue, but its also quite seasonal. where as sugar in our current environment is all year round 24/7 and super low energy expenditure to get and consume it.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI know, it is a metaphor. Some of our primate relatives live off fruit, but a) wild fruit is generally way less sugary than whatever we produce now, b) they are fairly far from us in many other regards (lifespan, anatomy, the ability to swing in the trees), so we cannot really derive relevant lessons on human metabolism from them. Our closest living relatives are chimps, who can eat tree bark and some leaves that we are unable to digest (they do not prefer them, but can eat them without ill consequences). Even at this relatively short evolutionary distance, our food requirements diverged.
- coolso 5y ago> Well we’re not designed. At least, that’s currently the prevailing theory among scientists.
- gruez 5y ago>we definitely aren't designed to consume the quantities of sugar that we on average do consume; and especially not non-stop for years and decades. That's a poor argument. We're also not "designed" to consume cooked foods, drink filtered tap water, and have access to modern medicine (eg. prescription/OTC drugs).
- inglor_cz 5y agoCooked food is a fairly old addition to our diet. Ancient humans learnt to control fire long before they evolved into the species that we now are. Some kind of adaptation must have happened - just look at our small teeth that are no more suitable for tearing raw meat apart. Filtered tap water isn't that different from natural water in streams, but I do not know nearly enough about water to dispute this. Prescription / OTC drugs can mess with us fairly seriously if not used carefully and in recommended quantities, so this is actually a good analogy. It is the dose that makes the poison. One Tylenol and/or 10 g of sugar per day won't probably harm you, but 20 Tylenols and half a pound of sugar per day, consumed every day for years and years, is another story.
- gruez 5y ago>Filtered tap water isn't that different from natural water in streams. complete with chlorine and flouride added? also, from a microbial activity and/or organic contaminants point of view, tap water probably has orders of magnitude less than most streams. >Prescription / OTC drugs can mess with us fairly seriously if not used carefully and in recommended quantities, so this is actually a good analogy. What's the equivalent statement for "the quantities of sugar that we on average do consume", but for drugs? I'd say that a big chunk of the population consumes infinitely more antidepressants and cholesterol-lowering drugs than we were "designed to consume".
- com2kid 5y ago> complete with chlorine and flouride added? also, from a microbial activity and/or organic contaminants point of view, tap water probably has orders of magnitude less than most streams. > I'd say that a big chunk of the population consumes infinitely more antidepressants and cholesterol-lowering drugs than we were "designed to consume". Connecting these two topics together, there are localities that have naturally occurring lithium in their water supply. Depression and suicide rates in these areas are lower than average. See https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry/article/association-between-naturally-occurring-lithium-in-drinking-water-and-suicide-rates-systematic-review-and-metaanalysis-of-ecological-studies/B7DDAF6E2A818C45EA64F3424E12D67A https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-...