2 ms·
> Setting a minimum medical loss ratios is not setting a minimum profit margin. It's setting a maximum profit margin. We don't have problems with businesses t
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Setting a minimum medical loss ratios is not setting a minimum profit margin.
It's setting a maximum profit margin.
We don't have problems with businesses trying to minimize their own profit margin.
> MCOs do not have a team of doctors and pharmacists scheming to approve medically unnecessary procedures.
All their competitors have to do is convince one of their patients that one of the procedures they're denying is medically necessary and they still get the bad press.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>It's setting a maximum profit margin. Is this a problem? As demonstrated by audited financial reports, there are many competing MCOs with many years of very small profit margins. These businesses clearly do not have pricing power, and are not businesses you get into to pocket lots of profit. >All their competitors have to do is convince one of their patients that one of the procedures they're denying is medically necessary and they still get the bad press. There is bad press about every single MCO out there, and they are processing millions of claims per day. I would need evidence to see that the bad press even means anything. Majority or at least plurality of people do not even get to choose their MCO.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> These businesses clearly do not have pricing power, and are not businesses you get into to pocket lots of profit. You're arguing against yourself there. If the market is really competitive then there is no need to set a maximum profit margin because anyone who tried to charge that much would lose business. Meanwhile, suppose that one provider was much better managed than the others. The mismanaged ones would simultaneously have high prices and low margins, because they're wasting the money. The well managed one could then have much higher margins even at the same or lower price. But if there is a profit cap and you're already at it, searching for further efficiency improvements costs you profit. If your margin is 20% and that's the cap, but you can get a 10% cost reduction, what do you do? If you lower prices, your competitors lower prices, and then you still have a 20% margin and they drop to a 10% margin. You gain no customers and reduce your absolute profits by 10% by making the same 20% margin on a 10% smaller total. If you burn the efficiency improvement on purpose, or don't look for it to begin with, you make more money. > Majority or at least plurality of people do not even get to choose their MCO. Somebody is choosing for them and that person doesn't want to take the blame for choosing one that denies claims. This is part of the reason why it works -- some HR drone making the decision isn't spending their own money, but they're the one who takes the blame for choosing the disreputable discount provider if there are problems.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI agree with your reasoning. I wonder if the Medical Loss Ratios are no longer a necessity, and were needed at the time of ACA’s passage due lack of all the other rules such as being able to deny for pre existing conditions and maximum lifetime benefit amounts (opposite of out of pocket maximums). However, since current profit margins are no where near 100% minus minimum medical loss ratios, I do not see how the existence of the minimum medical loss ratios would cause any MCO to be less incentivized to seek further efficiencies.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe incentive created by a profit cap is to launder the profits through something else. If 80% of the spend has to go to medical providers then the insurance company or its parent owns or gets some kind of kickbacks from some of the medical providers. The purposeful complexity of medical billing makes this easier to do and harder to detect, so who knows if it's happening, but incentive to do it exists so it probably is. This also lines up with the PR benefit in being able to claim a low profit margin and overhead on paper.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat is a bridge too far for me. I am going to assume the SEC published numbers have some resemblance to reality.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThink about how transfer pricing works for tax avoidance. It's not that they're necessarily lying, it's that they purposely structure their activities to produce the most financially advantageous numbers that are consistent with regulatory requirements.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat is the evidence though? Transfer pricing does not seem to be applicable to a managed care organization (health insurance company), which only operate in the US as far as I know, and do not have IP to transfer in the first place. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/transfer-pricing.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/transfer-pricing.asp I also do not see what the gain for shareholders would be in reporting lower profit margins.