3 ms·
This may be a cute picture but the real picture of the situation is rather bleak. All wireless systems need power amplifier (PA) and most of real-world PA has
by teleforce 5y ago
This may be a cute picture but the real picture of the situation is rather bleak.
All wireless systems need power amplifier (PA) and most of real-world PA has much less than 50% efficiency. In any system that incorporates power amplifier, the power consumption of the PA is usually more than 50% of the overall system power consumption. If the antenna is further up the line, roof or tower, then the actual power it deliver at the antenna is probably less than 10% of the original power supplied to the PA due to impedance mismatched, etc [1]. As of now, a single Starlink setup and installation requires about 180 watts of power and assuming the PA uses about the half the power consumption then it probably operating at 100 watts. I believe using the current setup most of the power is gone to waste, and only a few watts is actually being used for the transmitting and receiving the wireless signals.
Since now wireless systems are so pervasive due to popularity of 4G/5G cellular, WiFi and satellites perhaps it's good idea to estimate the amount of power wasted and fully being used for wireless transmission and reception globally. Recently, there is an article this year on HN that tells the story of remote radio station operator in Ontario Canada that has gone mostly off-grid by using solar because the cost of solar and battery storage systems have both decreased by approximately 90 per cent since 2010. However, it cannot goes fully off-grid due to the excessive power requirement of the wireless radio station's tower transmitter [2].
[1]How to Make a Digital Predistortion Solution Practical and Relevant:
https://www.analog.com/en/analog-dialogue/articles/how-to-make-a-digital-predistortion-solution-practical-and-relevant.html https://www.analog.com/en/analog-dialogue/articles/how-to-ma...
[2] Facing sky-high connection fees, rural Ontarians go off the grid:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28997995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28997995
- ncmncm 5y agoWhy are we stuck with impedance mismatches? Isn't that a matter of design?