3 ms·
Why? 1 Sv (over a year) equates to a 5.5% increase chance of fatal cancer within a lifetime. Assuming the dosage is linear (it isn't but we use a Linear _no thr
by godelski 5y ago
Why? 1 Sv (over a year) equates to a 5.5% increase chance of fatal cancer within a lifetime. Assuming the dosage is linear (it isn't but we use a Linear _no threshold_ model because it over estimates risk) 100mSv is a 0.55% increase in risk. So 50mSv is a 0.055% increase risk (note the parent is slightly wrong. Most countries and workers have a 20mSv maximum).
You're getting caught up in _detectable_ but not thinking enough about the actual level of risk. The danger/risk from 100mSv is far less of a risk than very common activities we do. Remember that that fatal cancer risk is over a lifetime (so let's say 40 years, or 0.01%/year if you receive that dose once). Smoking a cigarette a day (singular, not a pack) is a 30+% chance increase in stroke and heart disease. I'd argue that this is far more dangerous but something we don't worry about as much.
Humans are really just bad at estimating risk.
- mlyle 5y ago> (note the parent is slightly wrong. Most countries and workers have a 20mSv maximum). https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/occupational-dose.html https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/basic-ref/glossary/occupation... "The NRC requires its licensees to limit occupational exposure to 5,000 mrem (50 mSv) per year. Occupational dose does not include the dose received from natural background sources, doses received as a medical patient or participant in medical research programs, or "second-hand doses" received through exposure to individuals treated with radioactive materials."
- godelski 5y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to say here. NRC is a US government. I said _most countries_ which in fact includes countries other than America. The EU standard is 20mSv. You'll also notice that this NRC listing specifies which workers. For DOE 50 mSv is regulatory limit and 20mSv is administrative control level. Of course, all this also changes based on occupation. I mean astronauts are allowed higher levels and pilots lower. But most countries and (radiation) workers have a 20mSv limit.
- mlyle 5y ago> I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. NRC is a US government. I thought it was perhaps appropriate, if we're quantifying US Navy occupational exposure to a US citizen, to compare to US civilian reactor exposure limits. It doesn't seem appropriate to call me "wrong" in this context. > For DOE 50 mSv is regulatory limit and 20mSv is administrative control level. Sure: one needs controls well short of the regulatory limit to keep pretty much everyone short of the limit. Most nuclear medicine workers and reactor workers are well under 2mSv/year in the US. A few outliers end up with lifetime doses of a few hundred mSv. P.S. Something went wrong here: > 100mSv is a 0.55% increase in risk. So 50mSv is a 0.055% increase risk In that you halved the dosage but divided the risk by 10, when saying you were evaluating it under LNT.
- godelski 5y ago> In that you halved the dosage but divided the risk by 10, when saying you were evaluating it under LNT. Ops, that's my bad and it is too late to edit. Thanks for the correction.